Dataset Information

New method for calculating the absolute free energy of binding: the effect of a mobile loop on the avidin/biotin complex.

ABSTRACT: Hypothetical scanning molecular dynamics (HSMD) is a relatively new method for calculating the absolute free energy and entropy. HSMD is extended here for the first time for calculating the absolute free energy of binding, ?A(0), as applied to the avidin-biotin complex. With HSMD the ligand is built (more accurately reconstructed) from nothing in solvent and in the protein, in contrast to the commonly used methods where the ligand is annihilated (by thermodynamic integration) in these environments. Therefore, the end-point problem encountered with the latter methods does not exist with HSMD and the need for restraints is avoided. Also, the entropy of the ligand and water in both environments is obtained directly as a byproduct of the simulation. The binding mechanism of biotin to avidin involves a mobile loop that is expected to be in an open conformation in unbound avidin, which is changed to a closed one upon binding, that is, the loop moves to cover biotin in the active site. The contribution of the loop's conformational change to the total free energy of binding is calculated here for the first time. Our result, ?A(0) = -24.9 ± 7 covers the experimental value -20.7 kcal/mol within the error bars.

SUBMITTER: General IJ

PROVIDER: S-EPMC3042141 | biostudies-literature | 2011 Jan

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

New method for calculating the absolute free energy of binding: the effect of a mobile loop on the avidin/biotin complex.

General Ignacio J IJ Dragomirova Ralitsa R Meirovitch Hagai H

The journal of physical chemistry. B 20101215 1

Hypothetical scanning molecular dynamics (HSMD) is a relatively new method for calculating the absolute free energy and entropy. HSMD is extended here for the first time for calculating the absolute free energy of binding, ΔA(0), as applied to the avidin-biotin complex. With HSMD the ligand is built (more accurately reconstructed) from nothing in solvent and in the protein, in contrast to the commonly used methods where the ligand is annihilated (by thermodynamic integration) in these environmen ...[more]

PMID: 21158467

Similar Datasets

Project description:The loop 287-290 (Ile, Phe, Arg, and Phe) of the protein acetylcholinesterase (AChE) changes its structure upon interaction of AChE with diisopropylphosphorofluoridate (DFP). Reversible dissociation measurements suggest that the free-energy (F) penalty for the loop displacement is DeltaF=Ffree-Fbound approximately -4 kcal/mol. Therefore, this loop has been the target of two studies by Olson's group for testing the efficiency of procedures for calculating F. In this paper, we test for the first time the performance of our "hypothetical scanning molecular dynamics" (HSMD) method and the validity of the related modeling for a loop with bulky side chains in explicit water. Thus, we consider only atoms of the protein that are the closest to the loop (they constitute the "template"), where the rest of the atoms are ignored. The template's atoms are fixed in the X-ray coordinates of the free protein, and the loop is capped with a sphere of TIP3P water molecules; also, the X-ray structure of the bound loop is attached to the free template. We carry out two separate MD simulations starting from the free and bound X-ray structures, where only the atoms of the loop and water are allowed to move while the template-water and template-loop (AMBER) interactions are considered. The absolute Ffree and Fbound (of the loop and water) are calculated from the corresponding trajectories. A main objective of this paper is to assess the reliability of this model, and for this several template sizes are studied capped with 80-220 water molecules. We find that consistent results for the free energy (which also agree with the experimental data above) require a template larger than a minimal size and a number of water molecules approximately equal to the experimental density of bulk water. For example, we obtain DeltaFtotal=DeltaFwater+DeltaFloop=-3.1+/-2.5 and -3.6+/-4 kcal/mol for a template consisting of 944 atoms and a sphere containing 160 and 180 waters, respectively. Our calculations demonstrate the important contribution of water to the total free energy. Namely, for water densities close to the experimental value, DeltaFwater is always negative leading thereby to a negative DeltaFtotal (while DeltaFloop is always positive). Also, the contribution of the water entropy TDeltaSwater to DeltaFtotal is significant. Various aspects related to the efficiency of HSMD are tested and improved, and plans for future studies are discussed.

Project description:Estimation of the energy from a given Boltzmann sample is straightforward since one just has to average the contribution of the individual configurations. On the other hand, calculation of the absolute entropy, S (hence the absolute free energy F) is difficult because it depends on the entire (unknown) ensemble. We have developed a new method called "the hypothetical scanning molecular dynamics" (HSMD) for calculating the absolute S from a given sample (generated by any simulation technique). In other words, S (like the energy) is "written" on the sample configurations, where HSMD provides a prescription of how to "read" it. In practice, each sample conformation, i, is reconstructed with transition probabilities, and their product leads to the probability of i, hence to the entropy. HSMD is an exact method where all interactions are considered, and the only approximation is due to insufficient sampling. In previous studies HSMD (and HS Monte CarloHSMC) has been extended systematically to systems of increasing complexity, where the most recent is the seven-residue mobile loop, 304-310 (Gly-His-Gly-Ala-Gly-Gly-Ser) of the enzyme porcine pancreatic alpha-amylase modeled by the AMBER force field and AMBER with the implicit solvation GB/SA (paper I, Cheluvaraja, S.; Meirovitch, H. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2008, 4, 192). In the present paper we make a step further and extend HSMD to the same loop capped with TIP3P explicit water at 300 K. As in paper I, we are mainly interested in entropy and free energy differences between the free and bound microstates of the loop, which are obtained from two separate MD samples of these microstates. The contribution of the loop to S and F is calculated by HSMD and that of water by a particular thermodynamic integration procedure. As expected, the free microstate is more stable than the bound microstate by a total free energy difference, Ffree-Fbound=-4.8+/-1, as compared to -25.5 kcal/mol obtained with GB/SA. We find that relatively large systematic errors in the loop entropies, Sfree(loop) and Sbound(loop) are cancelled in their difference which is thus obtained efficiently and with high accuracy, i.e., with a statistical error of 0.1 kcal/mol. This cancellation, which has been observed in previous HSMD studies, is in accord with theoretical arguments given in paper I.

Project description:The hypothetical scanning molecular dynamics (HSMD) method is used here for calculating the absolute free energy of binding, ΔA(0) of the complex of the protein FKBP12 with the ligand SB2 (also denoted L8) - a system that has been studied previously for comparing the performance of different methods. Our preliminary study suggests that considering long-range electrostatics is imperative even for a hydrophobic ligand such as L8. Therefore the system is modeled by the AMBER force field using Particle Mesh Ewald (PME). HSMD consists of three stages applied to both the ligand-solvent and ligand-protein systems. (1) A small set of system configurations (frames) is extracted from an MD trajectory. (2) The entropy of the ligand in each frame is calculated by a reconstruction procedure. (3) The contribution of water and protein to ΔA(0) is calculated for each frame by gradually increasing the ligand-environment interactions from zero to their full value using thermodynamic integration (TI). Unlike the conventional methods, the structure of the ligand is kept fixed during TI, and HSMD is thus free from the end-point problem encountered with the double annihilation method (DAM); therefore, the need for applying restraints is avoided. Furthermore, unlike the conventional methods, the entropy of the ligand and water is obtained directly as a byproduct of the simulation. In this paper, in addition to the difference in the internal entropies of the ligand in the two environments, we calculate for the first time the external entropy of the ligand, which provides a measure for the size of the active site. We obtain ΔA(0) = -10.7 ±1.0 as compared to the experimental values -10.9 and -10.6 kcal/mol. However, a protein/water system treated by periodic boundary conditions grows significantly with increasing protein size and the computation of ΔA(0) would become expensive by all methods. Therefore, we also apply HSMD to FKBP12-L8 described by the GSBP/SSBP model of Roux's group (implemented in the software CHARMM) where only part of the protein and water around the active site are considered and long-range electrostatic effects are taken into account. For comparison this model was also treated by the double decoupling method (DDM). The two methods have led to comparable results for ΔA(0) which are somewhat lower than the experimental value. The ligand was found to be more confined in the active site described by GSBP/SSBP than by PME where its entropy in solvent is larger than in the active site by 1.7 and by 5.5 kcal/mol, respectively.

Dataset Information

New method for calculating the absolute free energy of binding: the effect of a mobile loop on the avidin/biotin complex.

Publications

New method for calculating the absolute free energy of binding: the effect of a mobile loop on the avidin/biotin complex.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets