Dataset Information

Using the biomass-ratio and idiosyncratic hypotheses to predict mixed-species litter decomposition.

ABSTRACT:

Background and aims

A test is made of the acceptability of the biomass-ratio hypothesis (BMRH), operationalized as community-weighted means (CWMs), and of a new hypothesis (idiosyncratic annulment), for predicting the decomposition of multispecies litter mixtures. Specifically, (1) does the BMRH based on monoculture decomposition rates introduce systematic over- or underestimation of rates in mixtures? and (2) does the degree of variability of these rates decrease with increasing species richness (SR) beyond that expected from purely mathematical causes?

Methods

Decomposition rates (mg g(-1) d(-1)) of litter from six tree species in microcosms were measured under controlled conditions during 18 weeks of incubation, alone and in all possible combinations of two, three, five and six species. Observed mixture decomposition rates were compared with those predicted by the BMRH using CWMs calculated from the monoculture rates, and the variability of the differences were compared with the SR of the mixture.

Key results

Both positive and negative deviations from expectation occurred at all levels of SR. The average differences between observed rates of mixtures and those predicted were approximately zero. Although variability in the prediction errors was independent of the SR, this variability between different mixtures having the same number of species decreased with increasing SR such that mixtures with the most species converged on the predicted values. This decrease in variance was not due to idiosyncratic annulment of higher order interactions between species.

Conclusions

The BMRH described the average response of litter mixtures. The decrease in variance and the convergence to the predicted values based on CWMs was not due to the 'idiosyncratic annulment' of species interactions but was a mathematical consequence of CWMs being sums of random variables. Since convergence occurs with increasing SR and since SR increases with increasing spatial scale, the spatial scale will be a determinant in the prediction of ecosystem processes, such as litter decomposition rates.

SUBMITTER: Tardif A

PROVIDER: S-EPMC3523654 | biostudies-literature | 2013 Jan

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Using the biomass-ratio and idiosyncratic hypotheses to predict mixed-species litter decomposition.

Tardif Antoine A Shipley Bill B

Annals of botany 20121106 1

<h4>Background and aims</h4>A test is made of the acceptability of the biomass-ratio hypothesis (BMRH), operationalized as community-weighted means (CWMs), and of a new hypothesis (idiosyncratic annulment), for predicting the decomposition of multispecies litter mixtures. Specifically, (1) does the BMRH based on monoculture decomposition rates introduce systematic over- or underestimation of rates in mixtures? and (2) does the degree of variability of these rates decrease with increasing species ...[more]

PMID: 23131299

Similar Datasets

Project description:Exploring how interactions between species evenness and dominant species identity affect litter decomposition processes is vital to understanding the relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning in the context of global changes. We carried out a 127-day litter decomposition experiment under controlled conditions, with interactions of four species evenness types (high, medium, low and single species) and three dominant species identity (Leymus chinensis, Serratula centauroides, Artemisia capillaris). After collecting the remaining litter, we estimated how evenness and dominant species identity affected litter mass loss rate, carbon (C) loss rate, nitrogen (N) loss rate and remaining litter C/N directly or indirectly, and assessed relative mixture effects (RMEs) on litter mass loss. The main results are shown as follows. (1) By generalized linear models, litter mass loss rate was significantly affected by evenness after 69-day decomposition; N loss rate was affected by dominant species identity after 69-day decomposition, with treatment dominated by Serratula centauroides being at least 9.26% higher than that dominated by any of other species; and remaining litter C/N was affected by the interactions between evenness and dominant species identity after 30-, 69- and 127-day decomposition. (2) Twenty-three out of 27 RMEs were additive, and dominant species identity showed a significant effect on RMEs after 127-day decomposition. (3) By confirmatory path analyses, litter mass loss rate was affected by dominant species identity directly after 127-day decomposition, and by both species evenness and dominant species identity indirectly which was mediated by initial litter functional dispersion (FDis) after 30- and 69-day decomposition; remaining litter C/N was affected by evenness indirectly which was mediated by initial litter FDis after 127-day decomposition. These findings highlight the importance of evenness and dominant species identity on litter decomposition. The study provides insights into communities during retrogressive successions in semi-arid grasslands in the context of global changes.

Project description:MotivationMethods for analyzing microbiome data generally fall into one of two groups: tests of the global hypothesis of any microbiome effect, which do not provide any information on the contribution of individual operational taxonomic units (OTUs); and tests for individual OTUs, which do not typically provide a global test of microbiome effect. Without a unified approach, the findings of a global test may be hard to resolve with the findings at the individual OTU level. Further, many tests of individual OTU effects do not preserve the false discovery rate (FDR).ResultsWe introduce the linear decomposition model (LDM), that provides a single analysis path that includes global tests of any effect of the microbiome, tests of the effects of individual OTUs while accounting for multiple testing by controlling the FDR, and a connection to distance-based ordination. The LDM accommodates both continuous and discrete variables (e.g. clinical outcomes, environmental factors) as well as interaction terms to be tested either singly or in combination, allows for adjustment of confounding covariates, and uses permutation-based P-values that can control for sample correlation. The LDM can also be applied to transformed data, and an 'omnibus' test can easily combine results from analyses conducted on different transformation scales. We also provide a new implementation of PERMANOVA based on our approach. For global testing, our simulations indicate the LDM provided correct type I error and can have comparable power to existing distance-based methods. For testing individual OTUs, our simulations indicate the LDM controlled the FDR well. In contrast, DESeq2 often had inflated FDR; MetagenomeSeq generally had the lowest sensitivity. The flexibility of the LDM for a variety of microbiome studies is illustrated by the analysis of data from two microbiome studies. We also show that our implementation of PERMANOVA can outperform existing implementations.Availability and implementationThe R package LDM is available on GitHub at https://github.com/yijuanhu/LDM in formats appropriate for Macintosh or Windows.Contactyijuan.hu@emory.edu.Supplementary informationSupplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Project description:Microbial communities are ubiquitous and often influence macroscopic properties of the ecosystems they inhabit. However, deciphering the functional relationship between specific microbes and ecosystem properties is an ongoing challenge owing to the complexity of the communities. This challenge can be addressed, in part, by integrating the advances in DNA sequencing technology with computational approaches like machine learning. Although machine learning techniques have been applied to microbiome data, use of these techniques remains rare, and user-friendly platforms to implement such techniques are not widely available. We developed a tool that implements neural network and random forest models to perform regression and feature selection tasks on microbiome data. In this study, we applied the tool to analyze soil microbiome (16S rRNA gene profiles) and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) data from a 44-day plant litter decomposition experiment. The microbiome data includes 1709 total bacterial operational taxonomic units (OTU) from 300+ microcosms. Regression analysis of predicted and actual DOC for a held-out test set of 51 samples yield Pearson's correlation coefficients of.636 and.676 for neural network and random forest approaches, respectively. Important taxa identified by the machine learning techniques are compared to results from a standard tool (indicator species analysis) widely used by microbial ecologists. Of 1709 bacterial taxa, indicator species analysis identified 285 taxa as significant determinants of DOC concentration. Of the top 285 ranked features determined by machine learning methods, a subset of 86 taxa are common to all feature selection techniques. Using this subset of features, prediction results for random permutations of the data set are at least equally accurate compared to predictions determined using the entire feature set. Our results suggest that integration of multiple methods can aid identification of a robust subset of taxa within complex communities that may drive specific functional outcomes of interest.

Dataset Information

Using the biomass-ratio and idiosyncratic hypotheses to predict mixed-species litter decomposition.

Background and aims

Methods

Key results

Conclusions

Publications

Using the biomass-ratio and idiosyncratic hypotheses to predict mixed-species litter decomposition.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets