Dataset Information

Comparison study on statistical features of predicted secondary structures for protein structural class prediction: From content to position.

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: Many content-based statistical features of secondary structural elements (CBF-PSSEs) have been proposed and achieved promising results in protein structural class prediction, but until now position distribution of the successive occurrences of an element in predicted secondary structure sequences hasn't been used. It is necessary to extract some appropriate position-based features of the secondary structural elements for prediction task. RESULTS: We proposed some position-based features of predicted secondary structural elements (PBF-PSSEs) and assessed their intrinsic ability relative to the available CBF-PSSEs, which not only offers a systematic and quantitative experimental assessment of these statistical features, but also naturally complements the available comparison of the CBF-PSSEs. We also analyzed the performance of the CBF-PSSEs combined with the PBF-PSSE and further constructed a new combined feature set, PBF11CBF-PSSE. Based on these experiments, novel valuable guidelines for the use of PBF-PSSEs and CBF-PSSEs were obtained. CONCLUSIONS: PBF-PSSEs and CBF-PSSEs have a compelling impact on protein structural class prediction. When combining with the PBF-PSSE, most of the CBF-PSSEs get a great improvement over the prediction accuracies, so the PBF-PSSEs and the CBF-PSSEs have to work closely so as to make significant and complementary contributions to protein structural class prediction. Besides, the proposed PBF-PSSE's performance is extremely sensitive to the choice of parameter k. In summary, our quantitative analysis verifies that exploring the position information of predicted secondary structural elements is a promising way to improve the abilities of protein structural class prediction.

SUBMITTER: Dai Q

PROVIDER: S-EPMC3652764 | biostudies-literature | 2013

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Comparison study on statistical features of predicted secondary structures for protein structural class prediction: From content to position.

Dai Qi Q Li Yan Y Liu Xiaoqing X Yao Yuhua Y Cao Yunjie Y He Pingan P

BMC bioinformatics 20130504

<h4>Background</h4>Many content-based statistical features of secondary structural elements (CBF-PSSEs) have been proposed and achieved promising results in protein structural class prediction, but until now position distribution of the successive occurrences of an element in predicted secondary structure sequences hasn't been used. It is necessary to extract some appropriate position-based features of the secondary structural elements for prediction task.<h4>Results</h4>We proposed some positio ...[more]

PMID: 23641706

Similar Datasets

Project description:BACKGROUND: RNA-binding proteins interact with specific RNA molecules to regulate important cellular processes. It is therefore necessary to identify the RNA interaction partners in order to understand the precise functions of such proteins. Protein-RNA interactions are typically characterized using in vivo and in vitro experiments but these may not detect all binding partners. Therefore, computational methods that capture the protein-dependent nature of such binding interactions could help to predict potential binding partners in silico. RESULTS: We have developed three methods to predict whether an RNA can interact with a particular RNA-binding protein using support vector machines and different features based on the sequence (the Oli method), the motif score (the OliMo method) and the secondary structure (the OliMoSS method). We applied these approaches to different experimentally-derived datasets and compared the predictions with RNAcontext and RPISeq. Oli outperformed OliMoSS and RPISeq, confirming our protein-specific predictions and suggesting that tetranucleotide frequencies are appropriate discriminative features. Oli and RNAcontext were the most competitive methods in terms of the area under curve. A precision-recall curve analysis achieved higher precision values for Oli. On a second experimental dataset including real negative binding information, Oli outperformed RNAcontext with a precision of 0.73 vs. 0.59. CONCLUSIONS: Our experiments showed that features based on primary sequence information are sufficiently discriminating to predict specific RNA-protein interactions. Sequence motifs and secondary structure information were not necessary to improve these predictions. Finally we confirmed that protein-specific experimental data concerning RNA-protein interactions are valuable sources of information that can be used for the efficient training of models for in silico predictions. The scripts are available upon request to the corresponding author.

Project description:BackgroundAccurate structure prediction methods play an important role for the understanding of RNA function. Energy-based, pseudoknot-free secondary structure prediction is one of the most widely used and versatile approaches, and improved methods for this task have received much attention over the past five years. Despite the impressive progress that as been achieved in this area, existing evaluations of the prediction accuracy achieved by various algorithms do not provide a comprehensive, statistically sound assessment. Furthermore, while there is increasing evidence that no prediction algorithm consistently outperforms all others, no work has been done to exploit the complementary strengths of multiple approaches.ResultsIn this work, we present two contributions to the area of RNA secondary structure prediction. Firstly, we use state-of-the-art, resampling-based statistical methods together with a previously published and increasingly widely used dataset of high-quality RNA structures to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of existing RNA secondary structure prediction procedures. The results from this evaluation clarify the performance relationship between ten well-known existing energy-based pseudoknot-free RNA secondary structure prediction methods and clearly demonstrate the progress that has been achieved in recent years. Secondly, we introduce AveRNA, a generic and powerful method for combining a set of existing secondary structure prediction procedures into an ensemble-based method that achieves significantly higher prediction accuracies than obtained from any of its component procedures.ConclusionsOur new, ensemble-based method, AveRNA, improves the state of the art for energy-based, pseudoknot-free RNA secondary structure prediction by exploiting the complementary strengths of multiple existing prediction procedures, as demonstrated using a state-of-the-art statistical resampling approach. In addition, AveRNA allows an intuitive and effective control of the trade-off between false negative and false positive base pair predictions. Finally, AveRNA can make use of arbitrary sets of secondary structure prediction procedures and can therefore be used to leverage improvements in prediction accuracy offered by algorithms and energy models developed in the future. Our data, MATLAB software and a web-based version of AveRNA are publicly available at http://www.cs.ubc.ca/labs/beta/Software/AveRNA.

Dataset Information

Comparison study on statistical features of predicted secondary structures for protein structural class prediction: From content to position.

Publications

Comparison study on statistical features of predicted secondary structures for protein structural class prediction: From content to position.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets