Dataset Information

Limits on the reproducibility of marker associations with southern leaf blight resistance in the maize nested association mapping population.

ABSTRACT:

Background

A previous study reported a comprehensive quantitative trait locus (QTL) and genome wide association study (GWAS) of southern leaf blight (SLB) resistance in the maize Nested Association Mapping (NAM) panel. Since that time, the genomic resources available for such analyses have improved substantially. An updated NAM genetic linkage map has a nearly six-fold greater marker density than the previous map and the combined SNPs and read-depth variants (RDVs) from maize HapMaps 1 and 2 provided 28.5 M genomic variants for association analysis, 17 fold more than HapMap 1. In addition, phenotypic values of the NAM RILs were re-estimated to account for environment-specific flowering time covariates and a small proportion of lines were dropped due to genotypic data quality problems. Comparisons of original and updated QTL and GWAS results confound the effects of linkage map density, GWAS marker density, population sample size, and phenotype estimates. Therefore, we evaluated the effects of changing each of these parameters individually and in combination to determine their relative impact on marker-trait associations in original and updated analyses.

Results

Of the four parameters varied, map density caused the largest changes in QTL and GWAS results. The updated QTL model had better cross-validation prediction accuracy than the previous model. Whereas joint linkage QTL positions were relatively stable to input changes, the residual values derived from those QTL models (used as inputs to GWAS) were more sensitive, resulting in substantial differences between GWAS results. The updated NAM GWAS identified several candidate genes consistent with previous QTL fine-mapping results.

Conclusions

The highly polygenic nature of resistance to SLB complicates the identification of causal genes. Joint linkage QTL are relatively stable to perturbations of data inputs, but their resolution is generally on the order of tens or more Mbp. GWAS associations have higher resolution, but lower power due to stringent thresholds designed to minimize false positive associations, resulting in variability of detection across studies. The updated higher density linkage map improves QTL estimation and, along with a much denser SNP HapMap, greatly increases the likelihood of detecting SNPs in linkage with causal variants. We recommend use of the updated genetic resources and results but emphasize the limited repeatability of small-effect associations.

SUBMITTER: Bian Y

PROVIDER: S-EPMC4300987 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:Maize is an important cereal crop in the world for feed, food, fodder, and raw materials of industries. Turcicum leaf blight (TLB) is a major foliar disease that can cause more than 50% yield losses in maize. Considering this, the molecular diversity, population structure, and genome-wide association study (GWAS) for TLB resistance were studied in 288 diverse inbred lines genotyped using 89 polymorphic simple sequence repeats (SSR) markers. These lines werescreened for TLB disease at two hot-spot locations under artificially inoculated conditions. The average percent disease incidence (PDI) calculated for each genotype ranged from 17 (UMI 1201) to 78% (IML 12-22) with an overall mean of 40%. The numbers of alleles detected at a locus ranged from twoto nine, with a total of 388 alleles. The polymorphic information content (PIC) of each marker ranged between 0.04 and 0.86. Out of 89 markers, 47 markers were highly polymorphic (PIC ≥ 0.60). This indicated that the SSR markers used were very informative and suitable for genetic diversity, population structure, and marker-trait association studies.The overall observed homozygosity for highly polymorphic markers was 0.98, which indicated that lines used were genetically pure. Neighbor-joining clustering, factorial analysis, and population structure studies clustered the 288 lines into 3-5 groups. The patterns of grouping were in agreement with the origin and pedigree records of the genotypesto a greater extent.A total of 94.10% lines were successfully assigned to one or another group at a membership probability of ≥0.60. An analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) revealed highly significant differences among populations and within individuals. Linkage disequilibrium for r2 and D' between loci ranged from 0 to 0.77 and 0 to 1, respectively. A marker trait association analysis carried out using a general linear model (GLM) and mixed linear model (MLM), identified 15 SSRs markers significantly associated with TLB resistance.These 15 markers were located on almost all chromosomes (Chr) except 7, 8, and 9. The phenotypic variation explained by these loci ranged from 6% (umc1367) to 26% (nc130, phi085). Maximum 7 associated markers were located together on Chr 2 and 5. The selected regions identified on Chr 2 and 5 corroborated the previous studies carried out in the Indian maize germplasm. Further, 11 candidate genes were identified to be associated with significant markers. The identified sources for TLB resistance and associated markers may be utilized in molecular breeding for the development of suitable genotypes.

Project description:Foliar diseases of maize cause severe economic losses in India and around the world. The increasing severity of maize leaf blight (MLB) over the past ten years necessitates rigorous identification and characterization of MLB-causing pathogens from different maize production zones to ensure the success of resistance breeding programs and the selection of appropriate disease management strategies. Although Bipolaris maydis is the primary pathogen causing MLB in India, other related genera such as Curvularia, Drechslera, and Exserohilum, and a taxonomically distant genus, Alternaria, are known to infect maize in other countries. To investigate the diversity of pathogens associated with MLB in India, 350 symptomatic leaf samples were collected between 2016 and 2018, from 20 MLB hotspots in nine states representing six ecological zones where maize is grown in India. Twenty representative fungal isolates causing MLB symptoms were characterized based on cultural, pathogenic, and molecular variability. Internal Transcribed Spacer (ITS) and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GADPH) gene sequence-based phylogenies showed that the majority of isolates (13/20) were Bipolaris maydis. There were also two Curvularia papendorfii isolates, and one isolate each of Bipolaris zeicola, Curvularia siddiquii, Curvularia sporobolicola, an unknown Curvularia sp. isolate phylogenetically close to C. graminicola, and an Alternaria sp. isolate. The B. zeicola, the aforesaid four Curvularia species, and the Alternaria sp. are the first reports of these fungi causing MLB in India. Pathogenicity tests on maize plants showed that isolates identified as Curvularia spp. and Alternaria sp. generally caused more severe MLB symptoms than those identified as Bipolaris spp. The diversity of fungi causing MLB, types of lesions, and variation in disease severity by different isolates described in this study provide baseline information for further investigations on MLB disease distribution, diagnosis, and management in India.

Project description:Gray leaf spot (GLS), caused by Cercospora zeae-maydis and Cercospora zeina, is one of the most important diseases of maize worldwide. The pathogen has a necrotrophic lifestyle and no major genes are known for GLS. Quantitative resistance, although poorly understood, is important for GLS management. We used genetic mapping to refine understanding of the genetic architecture of GLS resistance and to develop hypotheses regarding the mechanisms underlying quantitative disease resistance (QDR) loci. Nested association mapping (NAM) was used to identify 16 quantitative trait loci (QTL) for QDR to GLS, including seven novel QTL, each of which demonstrated allelic series with significant effects above and below the magnitude of the B73 reference allele. Alleles at three QTL, qGLS1.04, qGLS2.09, and qGLS4.05, conferred disease reductions of greater than 10%. Interactions between loci were detected for three pairs of loci, including an interaction between iqGLS4.05 and qGLS7.03. Near-isogenic lines (NILs) were developed to confirm and fine-map three of the 16 QTL, and to develop hypotheses regarding mechanisms of resistance. qGLS1.04 was fine-mapped from an interval of 27.0 Mb to two intervals of 6.5 Mb and 5.2 Mb, consistent with the hypothesis that multiple genes underlie highly significant QTL identified by NAM. qGLS2.09, which was also associated with maturity (days to anthesis) and with resistance to southern leaf blight, was narrowed to a 4-Mb interval. The distance between major leaf veins was strongly associated with resistance to GLS at qGLS4.05. NILs for qGLS1.04 were treated with the C. zeae-maydis toxin cercosporin to test the role of host-specific toxin in QDR. Cercosporin exposure increased expression of a putative flavin-monooxygenase (FMO) gene, a candidate detoxification-related gene underlying qGLS1.04. This integrated approach to confirming QTL and characterizing the potential underlying mechanisms advances the understanding of QDR and will facilitate the development of resistant varieties.