Target specificity of the CRISPR-Cas9 system.
Ontology highlight
ABSTRACT:
SUBMITTER: Wu X
PROVIDER: S-EPMC4338555 | biostudies-literature | 2014 Jun
REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature
Publications
Target specificity of the CRISPR-Cas9 system.
Wu Xuebing X Kriz Andrea J AJ Sharp Phillip A PA
Quantitative biology (Beijing, China) 20140601 2
The CRISPR-Cas9 system, naturally a defense mechanism in prokaryotes, has been repurposed as an RNA-guided DNA targeting platform. It has been widely used for genome editing and transcriptome modulation, and has shown great promise in correcting mutations in human genetic diseases. Off-target effects are a critical issue for all of these applications. Here we review the current status on the target specificity of the CRISPR-Cas9 system. ...[more]
Similar Datasets
Project description:The limited target specificity of CRISPR-Cas nucleases poses a challenge with respect to their application in research and therapy. Here, we present a simple and original strategy to enhance the specificity of CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing by coupling Cas9 to artificial inhibitory domains. Applying a combination of mathematical modeling and experiments, we first determined how CRISPR-Cas9 activity profiles relate to Cas9 specificity. We then used artificially weakened anti-CRISPR (Acr) proteins either coexpressed with or directly fused to Cas9 to fine-tune its activity toward selected levels, thereby achieving an effective kinetic insulation of ON- and OFF-target editing events. We demonstrate highly specific genome editing in mammalian cells using diverse single-guide RNAs prone to potent OFF-targeting. Last, we show that our strategy is compatible with different modes of delivery, including transient transfection and adeno-associated viral vectors. Together, we provide a highly versatile approach to reduce CRISPR-Cas OFF-target effects via kinetic insulation.
| S-EPMC7002122 | biostudies-literature
Project description:To study target sequence specificity, selectivity, and reaction kinetics of Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 activity, we challenged libraries of random variant targets with purified Cas9::guide RNA complexes in vitro. Cleavage kinetics were nonlinear, with a burst of initial activity followed by slower sustained cleavage. Consistent with other recent analyses of Cas9 sequence specificity, we observe considerable (albeit incomplete) impairment of cleavage for targets mutated in the PAM sequence or in "seed" sequences matching the proximal 8 bp of the guide. A second target region requiring close homology was located at the other end of the guide::target duplex (positions 13-18 relative to the PAM). Strikingly, a subset of variants which broke homology in the intervening region consistently increased the capacity of Cas9 to cleave in extended reactions. Sequences flanking the guide+PAM region had measurable (albeit modest) effects on cleavage. Taken together, these studies provide both a basis for predicting effective cleavage targets and a basis for potential optimization of guide RNAs to yield efficiency beyond that of the simple perfect-match guides. 118 samples anaylzed. Controls have con in sample name. To quantitatively measure cleavage efficiency of a single gRNA, we created a population of random variant target sequences to two gRNA targets. The targets used were "unc-22A", [a sequence from the well-characterized unc-22 gene of Caenorhabditis elegans], and "protospacer 4" (ps4), a previously characterized sequence from a natural spacer from S. pyogenes MGAS10750 . Using custom mixtures of oligonucleotide precursors for each base during chemical synthesis, a set of polymorphic target libraries ('Random Variant Libraries') were designed to have a baseline variation rate at each position. On each side of the gRNA homology and PAM regions, 6 bps of random sequence were added. The first base of intended gRNA homology is designated base 1 . The entire 35 bp random variant library mixture was cloned into a standard plasmid vector (pHRL-TK). Several thousand colonies from plates were washed in pools and prepared by standard plasmid preparation methods. The complexity of the libraries were estimated based on Illumina sequencing of the uncut libraries and filtering for minimum representation expected from the pooling. Approximately 1500-3000 unique species were obtained in the unc-22A libraries and 5000 unique sequences in the ps4 library (see Materials and Methods). To assay cleavage, purified Cas9 was first incubated with gRNA, followed by incubation with the variant library for various time points and under various conditions. DNA template is among the conditions varied in the experiments. After protein removal, flanking sequences outside of the target region are used for PCR amplification and plasmid cleavage was measured through loss of PCR products that span the region of interest. A set of perfectly matched targets and highly mutated versions present in the random variant library served as internal positive and negative controls respectively. A log retention score for each sequence in each experiment was calculated by quantifying the representation of each sequence before and after addition of the Cas9 protein. Two approaches were used for normalization: first we used a population of ps4 targets "spiked" into the library as an uncleaved control, second, we used a population of unc-22A targets with large numbers of variations from the perfect target (between 4 and 7), and hence likely limited if any cleavage. Equivalent results are obtained with these two normalization approaches (see Computational Methods for details). Retention scores are expressed as the log2 of the normalized ratio, so that a more negative retention score indicates efficient cleavage of substrate while a less negative score indicates less cleavage. Templates which are uncleaved will yield a retention score at or near zero. Comparisons between multiple experiments indicate strong correlation between independent retention measurements. GSM1410678-GSM1410761; AF_SOL*.dat' files contain the calculated final retentions for each experiment. Each experiment labeled: M-bM-^@M-^\AF_SOL_###_t###M-bM-^@M-^]. M-bM-^@M-^\AF_SOL_###M-bM-^@M-^] corresponds to the experiment run ID and M-bM-^@M-^\t###M-bM-^@M-^] corresponds to the incubation time of the experiment. For example AF_SOL_513_t360, corresponds to experiment 513 on the protospacer 4 guide and DNA target and the incubation time was 360 mins. The experimental conditions and ID can be found in the associated publication. GSM1544297-GSM1544332; unc*.dat file is a tab-delimited file of all considered sequences in each experiment. The names of the files and the AF_SOL_# run number can be found in the associated publication (Supplementary Materials) with the details of the conditions. Each filename starts with the type of gRNA used (either unc-22WT or the mutant version unc22C11G). The next number (#min) is indication of the time of incubation for the experiment and this is either followed by #pcr_AF_SOL_# or just AF_SOL_#. If followed by #pcr, that is the indication of the number of PCR cycles used in the experiments. Finally, AF_SOL_# denotes the sequencing run ID number.
2014-11-14 | E-GEOD-58426 | biostudies-arrayexpress
Project description:The CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing system has enhanced the development of genetically engineered animals for use in xenotransplantation. Potential limitations to the CRISPR/Cas9 system impacting the development of genetically engineered cells and animals include the creation of off-target mutations. We sought to develop a method to reduce the likelihood of off-target mutation while maintaining a high efficiency rate of desired genetic mutations for the GGTA1 gene. Extension of sgRNA length, responsible for recognition of the target DNA sequence for Cas9 cleavage, resulted in improved specificity for the GGTA1 gene and less off-target DNA cleavage. Three PAM sites were selected within exon 1 of the porcine GGTA1 gene and ten sgRNA of variable lengths were designed across these three sites. The sgRNA was tested against synthetic double stranded DNA templates replicating both the native GGTA1 DNA template and the two most likely off-target binding sites in the porcine genome. Cleavage ability for native and off-target DNA was determined by in vitro cleavage assays. Resulting cleavage products were analyzed to determine the cleavage efficiency of the Cas9/sgRNA complex. Extension of sgRNA length did not have a statistical impact on the specificity of the Cas9/sgRNA complex for PAM1 and PAM2 sites. At the PAM3 site, however, an observed increase in specificity for native versus off-target templates was seen with increased sgRNA length. In addition, distance between PAM site and the start codon had a significant impact on cleavage efficiency and target specificity, regardless of sgRNA length. Although the in vitro assays showed off-target cleavage, Sanger sequencing revealed that no off-target mutations were found in GGTA1 knockout cell lines or piglet. These results demonstrate an optimized method for improvement of the CRIPSR/Cas9 gene editing system by reducing the likelihood of damaging off-target mutations in GGTA1 knocked out cells destined for xenotransplant donor production.
| S-EPMC6903732 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Genomic engineering by the guide RNA (gRNA)-directed CRISPR/CAS9 is rapidly becoming a method of choice for various biological systems. However, pressing concerns remain regarding its off-target activities and wide variations in efficacies. While next generation sequencing (NGS) has been primarily used to evaluate the efficacies and off-target activities of gRNAs, it only detects the imperfectly repaired double strand DNA breaks (DSB) by the error-prone non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) mechanism and may not faithfully represent the DSB activities because the efficiency of NHEJ-mediated repair varies depending on the local chromatin environment. Here we describe a reporter system for unbiased detection and comparison of DSB activities that promises to improve the chance of success in genomic engineering and to facilitate large-scale screening of CAS9 activities and gRNA libraries. Additionally, we demonstrated that the tolerances to mismatches between a gRNA and the corresponding target DNA can occur at any position of the gRNA, and depend on both specific gRNA sequences and CAS9 constructs used.
| S-EPMC4252756 | biostudies-literature
Project description:To study target sequence specificity, selectivity, and reaction kinetics of Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 activity, we challenged libraries of random variant targets with purified Cas9::guide RNA complexes in vitro. Cleavage kinetics were nonlinear, with a burst of initial activity followed by slower sustained cleavage. Consistent with other recent analyses of Cas9 sequence specificity, we observe considerable (albeit incomplete) impairment of cleavage for targets mutated in the PAM sequence or in "seed" sequences matching the proximal 8 bp of the guide. A second target region requiring close homology was located at the other end of the guide::target duplex (positions 13-18 relative to the PAM). Strikingly, a subset of variants which broke homology in the intervening region consistently increased the capacity of Cas9 to cleave in extended reactions. Sequences flanking the guide+PAM region had measurable (albeit modest) effects on cleavage. Taken together, these studies provide both a basis for predicting effective cleavage targets and a basis for potential optimization of guide RNAs to yield efficiency beyond that of the simple perfect-match guides.
2014-11-14 | GSE58426 | GEO
Project description:CRISPR/Cas9 is a versatile genome-editing technology that is widely used for studying the functionality of genetic elements, creating genetically modified organisms as well as preclinical research of genetic disorders. However, the high frequency of off-target activity (≥50%)-RGEN (RNA-guided endonuclease)-induced mutations at sites other than the intended on-target site-is one major concern, especially for therapeutic and clinical applications. Here, we review the basic mechanisms underlying off-target cutting in the CRISPR/Cas9 system, methods for detecting off-target mutations, and strategies for minimizing off-target cleavage. The improvement off-target specificity in the CRISPR/Cas9 system will provide solid genotype-phenotype correlations, and thus enable faithful interpretation of genome-editing data, which will certainly facilitate the basic and clinical application of this technology.
| S-EPMC4877446 | biostudies-other
Project description:The clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat (CRISPR)-associated endonuclease 9 (CRISPR/Cas9) system has been demonstrated to be a robust genome engineering tool in a variety of organisms including plants. However, it has been shown that the CRISPR/Cas9 system cleaves genomic DNA sequences containing mismatches to the guide RNA strand. We expected that this low specificity could be exploited to induce multihomeologous and multiparalogous gene knockouts. In the case of polyploid plants, simultaneous modification of multiple homeologous genes, i.e. genes with similar but not identical DNA sequences, is often needed to obtain a desired phenotype. Even in diploid plants, disruption of multiparalogous genes, which have functional redundancy, is often needed. To validate the applicability of the CRISPR/Cas9 system to target mutagenesis of paralogous genes in rice, we designed a single-guide RNA (sgRNA) that recognized 20 bp sequences of cyclin-dependent kinase B2 (CDKB2) as an on-target locus. These 20 bp possess similarity to other rice CDK genes (CDKA1, CDKA2 and CDKB1) with different numbers of mismatches. We analyzed mutations in these four CDK genes in plants regenerated from Cas9/sgRNA-transformed calli and revealed that single, double and triple mutants of CDKA2, CDKB1 and CDKB2 can be created by a single sgRNA.
| S-EPMC4301742 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Development of the CRISPR-Cas9 gene-editing system has given rise to a new era of gene editing with wide applications in biology, medicine, agriculture, and other fields. However, the overexpression of Cas9 nuclease causes off-target effects and may trigger an immune response in vivo. Therefore, we constructed a self-restricting CRISPR-Cas9 system, where the target gene sequence corresponding to the guide RNA (gRNA) is inserted on either end of the Cas9 promoter. When double-strand breaks (DSBs) are induced in the target gene sequence, the Cas9 promoter is cut off and transcription ceases. With this system, expression of Cas9 protein at 60 h after transfection is only 10% that of the wild-type system, with about 70% promoter deletion efficiency. The target site editing efficiency and homologous recombination efficiency of the self-restricting system remain at about 50% and 30%, respectively, while the frequency of off-target indel formation decreased by 76.7%. Further, the number of indel types was also reduced from 13 to 2. Because this system does not include additional gRNA sequences, the possibility of introducing new off-target mutations is decreased. Importantly, this system is composed of a single plasmid, which could potentially be easily introduced in vivo using a viral vector or nanoparticles.
| S-EPMC7358219 | biostudies-literature
Project description:The CRISPR/Cas9 system has recently emerged as a powerful tool for functional genomic studies in Drosophila melanogaster. However, single-guide RNA (sgRNA) parameters affecting the specificity and efficiency of the system in flies are still not clear. Here, we found that off-target effects did not occur in regions of genomic DNA with three or more nucleotide mismatches to sgRNAs. Importantly, we document for a strong positive correlation between mutagenesis efficiency and sgRNA GC content of the six protospacer-adjacent motif-proximal nucleotides (PAMPNs). Furthermore, by injecting well-designed sgRNA plasmids at the optimal concentration we determined, we could efficiently generate mutations in four genes in one step. Finally, we generated null alleles of HP1a using optimized parameters through homology-directed repair and achieved an overall mutagenesis rate significantly higher than previously reported. Our work demonstrates a comprehensive optimization of sgRNA and promises to vastly simplify CRISPR/Cas9 experiments in Drosophila.
| S-EPMC4250831 | biostudies-literature
Project description:The development of programmable nucleases has enabled the application of new genome engineering strategies for cellular immunotherapy. While targeted nucleases have mostly been used to knock-out or knock-in genes in immune cells, the scarless exchange of entire immunogenomic alleles would be of great interest. In particular, reprogramming the polymorphic MHC locus could enable the creation of matched donors for allogeneic cellular transplantation. Here we show a proof-of-concept for reprogramming MHC-specificity by performing CRISPR-Cas9-assisted cassette exchange. Using murine antigen presenting cell lines (RAW264.7 macrophages), we demonstrate that the generation of Cas9-induced double-stranded breaks flanking the native MHC-I H2-Kd locus led to exchange of an orthogonal H2-Kb allele. MHC surface expression allowed for easy selection of reprogrammed cells by flow cytometry, thus obviating the need for additional selection markers. MHC-reprogrammed cells were fully functional as they could present H2-Kd-restricted peptide and activate cognate T cells. Finally, we investigated the role of various donor template formats on exchange efficiency, discovering that templates that underwent in situ linearization resulted in the highest MHC-reprogramming efficiency. These findings highlight a potential new approach for the correcting of MHC mismatches in cellular transplantation.
| S-EPMC5379551 | biostudies-literature