Dataset Information

Evaluating a variety of text-mined features for automatic protein function prediction with GOstruct.

ABSTRACT: Most computational methods that predict protein function do not take advantage of the large amount of information contained in the biomedical literature. In this work we evaluate both ontology term co-mention and bag-of-words features mined from the biomedical literature and analyze their impact in the context of a structured output support vector machine model, GOstruct. We find that even simple literature based features are useful for predicting human protein function (F-max: Molecular Function =0.408, Biological Process =0.461, Cellular Component =0.608). One advantage of using literature features is their ability to offer easy verification of automated predictions. We find through manual inspection of misclassifications that some false positive predictions could be biologically valid predictions based upon support extracted from the literature. Additionally, we present a "medium-throughput" pipeline that was used to annotate a large subset of co-mentions; we suggest that this strategy could help to speed up the rate at which proteins are curated.

SUBMITTER: Funk CS

PROVIDER: S-EPMC4441003 | biostudies-literature | 2015

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Evaluating a variety of text-mined features for automatic protein function prediction with GOstruct.

Funk Christopher S CS Kahanda Indika I Ben-Hur Asa A Verspoor Karin M KM

Journal of biomedical semantics 20150318

Most computational methods that predict protein function do not take advantage of the large amount of information contained in the biomedical literature. In this work we evaluate both ontology term co-mention and bag-of-words features mined from the biomedical literature and analyze their impact in the context of a structured output support vector machine model, GOstruct. We find that even simple literature based features are useful for predicting human protein function (F-max: Molecular Functio ...[more]

PMID: 26005564

Similar Datasets

Project description:BACKGROUND: Advances in sequencing technology over the past decade have resulted in an abundance of sequenced proteins whose function is yet unknown. As such, computational systems that can automatically predict and annotate protein function are in demand. Most computational systems use features derived from protein sequence or protein structure to predict function. In an earlier work, we demonstrated the utility of biomedical literature as a source of text features for predicting protein subcellular location. We have also shown that the combination of text-based and sequence-based prediction improves the performance of location predictors. Following up on this work, for the Critical Assessment of Function Annotations (CAFA) Challenge, we developed a text-based system that aims to predict molecular function and biological process (using Gene Ontology terms) for unannotated proteins. In this paper, we present the preliminary work and evaluation that we performed for our system, as part of the CAFA challenge. RESULTS: We have developed a preliminary system that represents proteins using text-based features and predicts protein function using a k-nearest neighbour classifier (Text-KNN). We selected text features for our classifier by extracting key terms from biomedical abstracts based on their statistical properties. The system was trained and tested using 5-fold cross-validation over a dataset of 36,536 proteins. System performance was measured using the standard measures of precision, recall, F-measure and overall accuracy. The performance of our system was compared to two baseline classifiers: one that assigns function based solely on the prior distribution of protein function (Base-Prior) and one that assigns function based on sequence similarity (Base-Seq). The overall prediction accuracy of Text-KNN, Base-Prior, and Base-Seq for molecular function classes are 62%, 43%, and 58% while the overall accuracy for biological process classes are 17%, 11%, and 28% respectively. Results obtained as part of the CAFA evaluation itself on the CAFA dataset are reported as well. CONCLUSIONS: Our evaluation shows that the text-based classifier consistently outperforms the baseline classifier that is based on prior distribution, and typically has comparable performance to the baseline classifier that uses sequence similarity. Moreover, the results suggest that combining text features with other types of features can potentially lead to improved prediction performance. The preliminary results also suggest that while our text-based classifier can be used to predict both molecular function and biological process in which a protein is involved, the classifier performs significantly better for predicting molecular function than for predicting biological process. A similar trend was observed for other classifiers participating in the CAFA challenge.

Project description:BackgroundMethods for predicting protein function directly from amino acid sequences are useful tools in the study of uncharacterized protein families and in comparative genomics. Until now, this problem has been approached using machine learning techniques that attempt to predict membership, or otherwise, to predefined functional categories or subcellular locations. A potential drawback of this approach is that the human-designated functional classes may not accurately reflect the underlying biology, and consequently important sequence-to-function relationships may be missed.ResultsWe show that a self-supervised data mining approach is able to find relationships between sequence features and functional annotations. No preconceived ideas about functional categories are required, and the training data is simply a set of protein sequences and their UniProt/Swiss-Prot annotations. The main technical aspect of the approach is the co-evolution of amino acid-based regular expressions and keyword-based logical expressions with genetic programming. Our experiments on a strictly non-redundant set of eukaryotic proteins reveal that the strongest and most easily detected sequence-to-function relationships are concerned with targeting to various cellular compartments, which is an area already well studied both experimentally and computationally. Of more interest are a number of broad functional roles which can also be correlated with sequence features. These include inhibition, biosynthesis, transcription and defence against bacteria. Despite substantial overlaps between these functions and their corresponding cellular compartments, we find clear differences in the sequence motifs used to predict some of these functions. For example, the presence of polyglutamine repeats appears to be linked more strongly to the "transcription" function than to the general "nuclear" function/location.ConclusionWe have developed a novel and useful approach for knowledge discovery in annotated sequence data. The technique is able to identify functionally important sequence features and does not require expert knowledge. By viewing protein function from a sequence perspective, the approach is also suitable for discovering unexpected links between biological processes, such as the recently discovered role of ubiquitination in transcription.

Dataset Information

Evaluating a variety of text-mined features for automatic protein function prediction with GOstruct.

Publications

Evaluating a variety of text-mined features for automatic protein function prediction with GOstruct.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets