Comparison of design strategies for ?-helix backbone modification in a protein tertiary fold.
Ontology highlight
ABSTRACT:
SUBMITTER: Tavenor NA
PROVIDER: S-EPMC4767680 | biostudies-literature | 2016 Mar
REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature
Publications
Comparison of design strategies for α-helix backbone modification in a protein tertiary fold.
Tavenor Nathan A NA Reinert Zachary E ZE Lengyel George A GA Griffith Brian D BD Horne W Seth WS
Chemical communications (Cambridge, England) 20160301 19
We report here the comparison of five classes of unnatural amino acid building blocks for their ability to be accommodated into an α-helix in a protein tertiary fold context. High-resolution structural characterization and analysis of folding thermodynamics yield new insights into the relationship between backbone composition and folding energetics in α-helix mimetics and suggest refined design rules for engineering the backbones of natural sequences. ...[more]
Similar Datasets
Project description:Many short beta-peptides adopt well-defined conformations in organic solvents, but specialized stabilizing elements are required for folding to occur in aqueous solution. Several different strategies to stabilize the 14-helical secondary structure in water have been developed, and here we provide a direct comparison of three such strategies. We have synthesized and characterized beta-peptide heptamers in which variously a salt bridge between side chains, a covalent link between side chains, or two cyclically constrained residues have been incorporated to promote 14-helicity. The incorporation of a salt bridge does not generate significant 14-helicity in water, according to CD and 2D NMR data. In contrast, incorporation either of a lactam bridge between side chains or of cyclic residues results in stable 14-helices in water. The beta-peptides featuring trans-2-aminocyclohexanecarboxylic acid (ACHC) residues show the highest 14-helical backbone stability, with hardly any sensitivity to pH or ionic strength. The beta-peptides featuring side-chain-to-side-chain cyclization show lower 14-helical backbone stability and higher sensitivity to pH and ionic strength, but increased order between the side chains because of the cyclization.
| S-EPMC3551619 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Computational design of binding sites in proteins remains difficult, in part due to limitations in our current ability to sample backbone conformations that enable precise and accurate geometric positioning of side chains during sequence design. Here we present a benchmark framework for comparison between flexible-backbone design methods applied to binding interactions. We quantify the ability of different flexible backbone design methods in the widely used protein design software Rosetta to recapitulate observed protein sequence profiles assumed to represent functional protein/protein and protein/small molecule binding interactions. The CoupledMoves method, which combines backbone flexibility and sequence exploration into a single acceptance step during the sampling trajectory, better recapitulates observed sequence profiles than the BackrubEnsemble and FastDesign methods, which separate backbone flexibility and sequence design into separate acceptance steps during the sampling trajectory. Flexible-backbone design with the CoupledMoves method is a powerful strategy for reducing sequence space to generate targeted libraries for experimental screening and selection.
| S-EPMC6901717 | biostudies-literature
Project description:In the fold recognition approach to structure prediction, a sequence is tested for compatibility with an already known fold. For membrane proteins, however, few folds have been determined experimentally. Here the feasibility of computing the vast majority of likely membrane protein folds is tested. The results indicate that conformation space can be effectively sampled for small numbers of helices. The vast majority of potential monomeric membrane protein structures can be represented by about 30-folds for three helices, but increases exponentially to about 1,500,000 folds for seven helices. The generated folds could serve as templates for fold recognition or as starting points for conformational searches that are well distributed throughout conformation space.
| S-EPMC2144225 | biostudies-other
Project description:Designing novel proteins to perform desired functions, such as binding or catalysis, is a major goal in synthetic biology. A variety of computational approaches can aid in this task. An energy-based framework rooted in the sequence-structure statistics of tertiary motifs (TERMs) can be used for sequence design on predefined backbones. Neural network models that use backbone coordinate-derived features provide another way to design new proteins. In this work, we combine the two methods to make neural structure-based models more suitable for protein design. Specifically, we supplement backbone-coordinate features with TERM-derived data, as inputs, and we generate energy functions as outputs. We present two architectures that generate Potts models over the sequence space: TERMinator, which uses both TERM-based and coordinate-based information, and COORDinator, which uses only coordinate-based information. Using these two models, we demonstrate that TERMs can be utilized to improve native sequence recovery performance of neural models. Furthermore, we demonstrate that sequences designed by TERMinator are predicted to fold to their target structures by AlphaFold. Finally, we show that both TERMinator and COORDinator learn notions of energetics, and these methods can be fine-tuned on experimental data to improve predictions. Our results suggest that using TERM-based and coordinate-based features together may be beneficial for protein design and that structure-based neural models that produce Potts energy tables have utility for flexible applications in protein science.
| S-EPMC9854172 | biostudies-literature
Project description:The prospect of recreating the complex structural hierarchy of protein folding in synthetic oligomers with backbones that are artificial in covalent structure ("foldamers") has long fascinated chemists. Foldamers offer complex functions from biostable scaffolds and have found widespread applications in fields from biomedical to materials science. Most precedent has focused on isolated secondary structures or their assemblies. In considering the goal of complex protein-like tertiary folding patterns, a key barrier became apparent. How does one design a backbone with covalent connectivity and a sequence of side-chain functional groups that will support defined intramolecular packing of multiple artificial secondary structures? Two developments were key to overcoming this challenge. First was the recognition of the power of blending ?-amino acid residues with monomers differing in backbone connectivity to create "heterogeneous-backbone" foldamers. Second was the finding that replacing some of the natural ?-residues in a biological sequence with artificial-backbone variants can result in a mimic that retains both the fold and function of the native sequence and, in some cases, gains advantageous characteristics. Taken together, these precedents lead to a view of a protein as chemical entity having two orthogonal sequences: a sequence of side-chain functional groups and a separate sequence of backbone units displaying those functional groups. In this Account, we describe our lab's work over the last ?10 years to leverage the above concept of protein sequence duality in order to develop design principles for constructing heterogeneous-backbone foldamers that adopt complex protein-like tertiary folds. Fundamental to the approach is the utilization of a variety of artificial building blocks (e.g., d-?-residues, C?-Me-?-residues, N-Me-?-residues, ?-residues, ?-residues, ?-residues, polymer segments) in concert, replacing a fraction of ?-residues in a given prototype sequence. We provide an overview of the state-of-the-art in terms of design principles for choosing substitutions based on consideration of local secondary structure and retention of key side-chain functional groups. We survey high-resolution structures of backbone-modified proteins to illustrate how diverse artificial moieties are accommodated in tertiary fold contexts. We detail efforts to elucidate how backbone alteration impacts folding thermodynamics and describe how such data informs the development of improved design rules. Collectively, a growing body of results by our lab and others spanning multiple protein systems suggests there is a great deal of plasticity with respect to the backbone chemical structures upon which sequence-encoded tertiary folds can manifest. Moreover, these efforts suggest sequence-guided backbone alteration as a broadly applicable strategy for generating foldamers with complex tertiary folding patterns. We conclude by offering some perspective regarding the near future of this field, in terms of unanswered questions, technological needs, and opportunities for new areas of inquiry.
| S-EPMC5953838 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Helix-hairpin-helix (HhH) is a widespread motif involved in non-sequence-specific DNA binding. The majority of HhH motifs function as DNA-binding modules, however, some of them are used to mediate protein-protein interactions or have acquired enzymatic activity by incorporating catalytic residues (DNA glycosylases). From sequence and structural analysis of HhH-containing proteins we conclude that most HhH motifs are integrated as a part of a five-helical domain, termed (HhH)(2) domain here. It typically consists of two consecutive HhH motifs that are linked by a connector helix and displays pseudo-2-fold symmetry. (HhH)(2) domains show clear structural integrity and a conserved hydrophobic core composed of seven residues, one residue from each alpha-helix and each hairpin, and deserves recognition as a distinct protein fold. In addition to known HhH in the structures of RuvA, RadA, MutY and DNA-polymerases, we have detected new HhH motifs in sterile alpha motif and barrier-to-autointegration factor domains, the alpha-subunit of Escherichia coli RNA-polymerase, DNA-helicase PcrA and DNA glycosylases. Statistically significant sequence similarity of HhH motifs and pronounced structural conservation argue for homology between (HhH)(2) domains in different protein families. Our analysis helps to clarify how non-symmetric protein motifs bind to the double helix of DNA through the formation of a pseudo-2-fold symmetric (HhH)(2) functional unit.
| S-EPMC102670 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Protein design remains an important problem in computational structural biology. Current computational protein design methods largely use physics-based methods, which make use of information from a single protein structure. This is despite the fact that multiple structures of many protein folds are now readily available in the PDB. While ensemble protein design methods can use multiple protein structures, they treat each structure independently. Here, we introduce a flexible backbone strategy, FlexiBaL-GP, which learns global protein backbone movements directly from multiple protein structures. FlexiBaL-GP uses the machine learning method of Gaussian Process Latent Variable Models to learn a lower dimensional representation of the protein coordinates that best represent backbone movements. These learned backbone movements are used to explore alternative protein backbones, while engineering a protein within a parallel tempered MCMC framework. Using the human ubiquitin-USP21 complex as a model we demonstrate that our design strategy outperforms current strategies for the interface design task of identifying tight binding ubiquitin variants for USP21.
| S-EPMC5587332 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Backbone-backbone hydrogen-bonding interactions are a ubiquitous and highly conserved structural feature of proteins that adopt the same fold (i.e., have the same overall backbone topology). This work addresses the question of whether or not this structural conservation is also reflected as a thermodynamic conservation. Reported here is a comparative thermodynamic analysis of backbone hydrogen bonds in two proteins that adopt the same fold but are unrelated at the primary amino acid sequence level. With amide-to-ester bond mutations introduced by total chemical synthesis methods, the thermodynamic consequences of backbone-backbone hydrogen-bond deletions at five different structurally equivalent positions throughout the beta-alpha-alpha fold of Arc repressor and CopG were assessed. The ester bond-containing analogues all folded into native-like three-dimensional structures that were destabilized from 2.5 to 6.0 kcal/(mol dimer) compared with wild-type controls. Remarkably, the five paired analogues with amide-to-ester bond mutations at structurally equivalent positions were destabilized to exactly the same degree, regardless of the degree to which the mutation site was buried in the structure. The results are interpreted as evidence that the thermodynamics of backbone-backbone hydrogen-bonding interactions in a protein fold are conserved.
| S-EPMC1413781 | biostudies-literature
Project description:The mimicry of protein tertiary structure by oligomers with unnatural backbones is a significant contemporary research challenge. Among common elements of secondary structure found in natural proteins, sheets have proven the most difficult to address. Here, we report the systematic comparison of different strategies for peptide backbone modification in β-sheets with the goal of identifying the best method for replacing a multi-stranded sheet in a protein tertiary fold. The most effective sheet modifications examined led to native-like tertiary folding behavior with a thermodynamic folded stability comparable to the prototype protein on which the modified backbones are based.
| S-EPMC4129447 | biostudies-literature
Project description:In recent years, there have been significant advances in the field of computational protein design including the successful computational design of enzymes based on backbone scaffolds from experimentally solved structures. It is likely that large-scale sampling of protein backbone conformations will become necessary as further progress is made on more complicated systems. Removing the constraint of having to use scaffolds based on known protein backbones is a potential method of solving the problem. With this application in mind, we describe a method to systematically construct a large number of de novo backbone structures from idealized topological forms in a top-down hierarchical approach. The structural properties of these novel backbone scaffolds were analyzed and compared with a set of high-resolution experimental structures from the protein data bank (PDB). It was found that the Ramachandran plot distribution and relative gamma- and beta-turn frequencies were similar to those found in the PDB. The de novo scaffolds were sequence designed with RosettaDesign, and the energy distributions and amino acid compositions were comparable with the results for redesigned experimentally solved backbones.
| S-EPMC2841848 | biostudies-literature