Dataset Information

Novel Alzheimer's disease subtypes identified using a data and knowledge driven strategy.

ABSTRACT: The population of adults with Alzheimer's disease (AD) varies in needs and outcomes. The heterogeneity of current AD diagnostic subgroups impedes the use of data analytics in clinical trial design and translation of findings into improved care. The purpose of this project was to define more clinically-homogeneous groups of AD patients and link clinical characteristics with biological markers. We used an innovative big data analysis strategy, the 3C strategy, that incorporates medical knowledge into the data analysis process. A large set of preprocessed AD Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) data was analyzed with 3C. The data analysis yielded 6 new disease subtypes, which differ from the assigned diagnosis types and present different patterns of clinical measures and potential biomarkers. Two of the subtypes, "Anosognosia dementia" and "Insightful dementia", differentiate between severe participants based on clinical characteristics and biomarkers. The "Uncompensated mild cognitive impairment (MCI)" subtype, demonstrates clinical, demographic and imaging differences from the "Affective MCI" subtype. Differences were also observed between the "Worried Well" and "Healthy" clusters. The use of data-driven analysis yielded sub-phenotypic clinical clusters that go beyond current diagnoses and are associated with biomarkers. Such homogenous sub-groups can potentially form the basis for enhancement of brain medicine research.

SUBMITTER: Mitelpunkt A

PROVIDER: S-EPMC6987140 | biostudies-literature | 2020 Jan

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Novel Alzheimer's disease subtypes identified using a data and knowledge driven strategy.

Mitelpunkt Alexis A Galili Tal T Kozlovski Tal T Bregman Noa N Shachar Netta N Markus-Kalish Mira M Benjamini Yoav Y

Scientific reports 20200128 1

The population of adults with Alzheimer's disease (AD) varies in needs and outcomes. The heterogeneity of current AD diagnostic subgroups impedes the use of data analytics in clinical trial design and translation of findings into improved care. The purpose of this project was to define more clinically-homogeneous groups of AD patients and link clinical characteristics with biological markers. We used an innovative big data analysis strategy, the 3C strategy, that incorporates medical knowledge i ...[more]

PMID: 31992745

Similar Datasets

Project description:ImportanceUndetected biological heterogeneity adversely impacts trials in Alzheimer's disease because rate of cognitive decline - and perhaps response to treatment - differs in subgroups. Recent results show that data-driven approaches can unravel the heterogeneity of Alzheimer's disease progression. The resulting stratification is yet to be leveraged in clinical trials.ObjectiveInvestigate whether image-based data-driven disease progression modelling could identify baseline biological heterogeneity in a clinical trial, and whether these subgroups have prognostic or predictive value.DesignScreening data from the Anti-Amyloid Treatment in Asymptomatic Alzheimer Disease (A4) Study collected between April 2014 and December 2017, and longitudinal data from the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) observational study downloaded in February 2022 were used.SettingThe A4 Study is an interventional trial involving 67 sites in the US, Canada, Australia, and Japan. ADNI is a multi-center observational study in North America.ParticipantsCognitively unimpaired amyloid-positive participants with a 3-Tesla T1-weighted MRI scan. Amyloid positivity was determined using florbetapir PET imaging (in A4) and CSF Aβ(1-42) (in ADNI).Main outcomes and measuresRegional volumes estimated from MRI scans were used as input to the Subtype and Stage Inference (SuStaIn) algorithm. Outcomes included cognitive test scores and SUVr values from florbetapir and flortaucipir PET.ResultsWe included 1,240 Aβ+ participants (and 407 Aβ- controls) from the A4 Study, and 731 A4-eligible ADNI participants. SuStaIn identified three neurodegeneration subtypes - Typical, Cortical, Subcortical - comprising 523 (42%) individuals. The remainder are designated subtype zero (insufficient atrophy). Baseline PACC scores (A4 primary outcome) were significantly worse in the Cortical subtype (median = -1.27, IQR=[-3.34,0.83]) relative to both subtype zero (median=-0.013, IQR=[-1.85,1.67], P<.0001) and the Subcortical subtype (median=0.03, IQR=[-1.78,1.61], P=.0006). In ADNI, over a four-year period (comparable to A4), greater cognitive decline in the mPACC was observed in both the Typical (-0.23/yr; 95% CI, [-0.41,-0.05]; P=.01) and Cortical (-0.24/yr; [-0.42,-0.06]; P=.009) subtypes, as well as the CDR-SB (Typical: +0.09/yr, [0.06,0.12], P<.0001; and Cortical: +0.07/yr, [0.04,0.10], P<.0001).Conclusions and relevanceIn a large secondary prevention trial, our image-based model detected neurodegenerative heterogeneity predictive of cognitive heterogeneity. We argue that such a model is a valuable tool to be considered in future trial design to control for previously undetected variance.

Project description:Alzheimer's disease is a highly heterogeneous disease in which different biomarkers are dynamic over different windows of the decades-long pathophysiological processes, and potentially have distinct involvement in different subgroups. Subtype and Stage Inference is an unsupervised learning algorithm that disentangles the phenotypic heterogeneity and temporal progression of disease biomarkers, providing disease insight and quantitative estimates of individual subtype and stage. However, a key limitation of Subtype and Stage Inference is that it requires a complete set of biomarkers for each subject, reducing the number of datapoints available for model fitting and limiting applications of Subtype and Stage Inference to modalities that are widely collected, e.g. volumetric biomarkers derived from structural MRI. In this study, we adapted the Subtype and Stage Inference algorithm to handle missing data, enabling the application of Subtype and Stage Inference to multimodal data (magnetic resonance imaging, positron emission tomography, cerebrospinal fluid and cognitive tests) from 789 participants in the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative. Missing-data Subtype and Stage Inference identified five subtypes having distinct progression patterns, which we describe by the earliest unique abnormality as 'Typical AD with Early Tau', 'Typical AD with Late Tau', 'Cortical', 'Cognitive' and 'Subcortical'. These new multimodal subtypes were differentially associated with age, years of education, Apolipoprotein E (APOE4) status, white matter hyperintensity burden and the rate of conversion from mild cognitive impairment to Alzheimer's disease, with the 'Cognitive' subtype showing the fastest clinical progression, and the 'Subcortical' subtype the slowest. Overall, we demonstrate that missing-data Subtype and Stage Inference reveals a finer landscape of Alzheimer's disease subtypes, each of which are associated with different risk factors. Missing-data Subtype and Stage Inference has broad utility, enabling the prediction of progression in a much wider set of individuals, rather than being restricted to those with complete data.

Dataset Information

Novel Alzheimer's disease subtypes identified using a data and knowledge driven strategy.

Publications

Novel Alzheimer's disease subtypes identified using a data and knowledge driven strategy.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets