Dataset Information

Pathway-Activity Likelihood Analysis and Metabolite Annotation for Untargeted Metabolomics Using Probabilistic Modeling.

ABSTRACT: Motivation: Untargeted metabolomics comprehensively characterizes small molecules and elucidates activities of biochemical pathways within a biological sample. Despite computational advances, interpreting collected measurements and determining their biological role remains a challenge. Results: To interpret measurements, we present an inference-based approach, termed Probabilistic modeling for Untargeted Metabolomics Analysis (PUMA). Our approach captures metabolomics measurements and the biological network for the biological sample under study in a generative model and uses stochastic sampling to compute posterior probability distributions. PUMA predicts the likelihood of pathways being active, and then derives probabilistic annotations, which assign chemical identities to measurements. Unlike prior pathway analysis tools that analyze differentially active pathways, PUMA defines a pathway as active if the likelihood that the path generated the observed measurements is above a particular (user-defined) threshold. Due to the lack of "ground truth" metabolomics datasets, where all measurements are annotated and pathway activities are known, PUMA is validated on synthetic datasets that are designed to mimic cellular processes. PUMA, on average, outperforms pathway enrichment analysis by 8%. PUMA is applied to two case studies. PUMA suggests many biological meaningful pathways as active. Annotation results were in agreement to those obtained using other tools that utilize additional information in the form of spectral signatures. Importantly, PUMA annotates many measurements, suggesting 23 chemical identities for metabolites that were previously only identified as isomers, and a significant number of additional putative annotations over spectral database lookups. For an experimentally validated 50-compound dataset, annotations using PUMA yielded 0.833 precision and 0.676 recall.

SUBMITTER: Hosseini R

PROVIDER: S-EPMC7281100 | biostudies-literature | 2020 May

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Pathway-Activity Likelihood Analysis and Metabolite Annotation for Untargeted Metabolomics Using Probabilistic Modeling.

Hosseini Ramtin R Hassanpour Neda N Liu Li-Ping LP Hassoun Soha S

Metabolites 20200503 5

<b>Motivation</b>: Untargeted metabolomics comprehensively characterizes small molecules and elucidates activities of biochemical pathways within a biological sample. Despite computational advances, interpreting collected measurements and determining their biological role remains a challenge. <b>Results</b>: To interpret measurements, we present an inference-based approach, termed Probabilistic modeling for Untargeted Metabolomics Analysis (PUMA). Our approach captures metabolomics measurements ...[more]

PMID: 32375258

Similar Datasets

Project description:Retention time information is used for metabolite annotation in metabolomic experiments. But its usefulness is hindered by the availability of experimental retention time data in metabolomic databases, and by the lack of reproducibility between different chromatographic methods. Accurate prediction of retention time for a given chromatographic method would be a valuable support for metabolite annotation. We have trained state-of-the-art machine learning regressors using the 80, 038 experimental retention times from the METLIN Small Molecule Retention Tim (SMRT) dataset. The models included deep neural networks, deep kernel learning, several gradient boosting models, and a blending approach. 5, 666 molecular descriptors and 2, 214 fingerprints (MACCS166, Extended Connectivity, and Path Fingerprints fingerprints) were generated with the alvaDesc software. The models were trained using only the descriptors, only the fingerprints, and both types of features simultaneously. Bayesian hyperparameter search was used for parameter tuning. To avoid data-leakage when reporting the performance metrics, nested cross-validation was employed. The best results were obtained by a heavily regularized deep neural network trained with cosine annealing warm restarts and stochastic weight averaging, achieving a mean and median absolute errors of [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text], respectively. To the best of our knowledge, these are the most accurate predictions published up to date over the SMRT dataset. To project retention times between chromatographic methods, a novel Bayesian meta-learning approach that can learn from just a few molecules is proposed. By applying this projection between the deep neural network retention time predictions and a given chromatographic method, our approach can be integrated into a metabolite annotation workflow to obtain z-scores for the candidate annotations. To this end, it is enough that just as few as 10 molecules of a given experiment have been identified (probably by using pure metabolite standards). The use of z-scores permits considering the uncertainty in the projection when ranking candidates, and not only the accuracy. In this scenario, our results show that in 68% of the cases the correct molecule was among the top three candidates filtered by mass and ranked according to z-scores. This shows the usefulness of this information to support metabolite annotation. Python code is available on GitHub at https://github.com/constantino-garcia/cmmrt.

Project description:Computational metabolite annotation in untargeted profiling aims at uncovering neutral molecular masses of underlying metabolites and assign those with putative identities. Existing annotation strategies rely on the observation and annotation of adducts to determine metabolite neutral masses. However, a significant fraction of features usually detected in untargeted experiments remains unannotated, which limits our ability to determine neutral molecular masses. Despite the availability of tools to annotate, relatively few of them benefit from the inherent presence of in-source fragments in liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry. In this study, we introduce a strategy to annotate in-source fragments in untargeted data using low-energy tandem mass spectrometry (MS) spectra from the METLIN library. Our algorithm, MISA (METLIN-guided in-source annotation), compares detected features against low-energy fragments from MS/MS spectra, enabling robust annotation and putative identification of metabolic features based on low-energy spectral matching. The algorithm was evaluated through an annotation analysis of a total of 140 metabolites across three different sets of biological samples analyzed with liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. Results showed that, in cases where adducts were not formed or detected, MISA was able to uncover neutral molecular masses by in-source fragment matching. MISA was also able to provide putative metabolite identities via two annotation scores. These scores take into account the number of in-source fragments matched and the relative intensity similarity between the experimental data and the reference low-energy MS/MS spectra. Overall, results showed that in-source fragmentation is a highly frequent phenomena that should be considered for comprehensive feature annotation. Thus, combined with adduct annotation, this strategy adds a complementary annotation layer, enabling in-source fragments to be annotated and increasing putative identification confidence. The algorithm is integrated into the XCMS Online platform and is freely available at http://xcmsonline.scripps.edu .

Dataset Information

Pathway-Activity Likelihood Analysis and Metabolite Annotation for Untargeted Metabolomics Using Probabilistic Modeling.

Publications

Pathway-Activity Likelihood Analysis and Metabolite Annotation for Untargeted Metabolomics Using Probabilistic Modeling.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets