Dataset Information

On the impact of service-oriented patterns on software evolvability: a controlled experiment and metric-based analysis.

ABSTRACT:

Background

Design patterns are supposed to improve various quality attributes of software systems. However, there is controversial quantitative evidence of this impact. Especially for younger paradigms such as service- and Microservice-based systems, there is a lack of empirical studies.

Objective

In this study, we focused on the effect of four service-based patterns-namely Process Abstraction, Service Façade, Decomposed Capability, and Event-Driven Messaging-on the evolvability of a system from the viewpoint of inexperienced developers.

Method

We conducted a controlled experiment with Bachelor students (N = 69). Two functionally equivalent versions of a service-based web shop-one with patterns (treatment group), one without (control group)-had to be changed and extended in three tasks. We measured evolvability by the effectiveness and efficiency of the participants in these tasks. Additionally, we compared both system versions with nine structural maintainability metrics for size, granularity, complexity, cohesion, and coupling.

Results

Both experiment groups were able to complete a similar number of tasks within the allowed 90 min. Median effectiveness was 1/3. Mean efficiency was 12% higher in the treatment group, but this difference was not statistically significant. Only for the third task, we found statistical support for accepting the alternative hypothesis that the pattern version led to higher efficiency. In the metric analysis, the pattern version had worse measurements for size and granularity while simultaneously having slightly better values for coupling metrics. Complexity and cohesion were not impacted.

Interpretation

For the experiment, our analysis suggests that the difference in efficiency is stronger with more experienced participants and increased from task to task. With respect to the metrics, the patterns introduce additional volume in the system, but also seem to decrease coupling in some areas.

Conclusions

Overall, there was no clear evidence for a decisive positive effect of using service-based patterns, neither for the student experiment nor for the metric analysis. This effect might only be visible in an experiment setting with higher initial effort to understand the system or with more experienced developers.

SUBMITTER: Bogner J

PROVIDER: S-EPMC7924695 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:Scientific services in the area of OMICS research is becoming increasingly popular. In gen- eral omics research can produce a massive amount of data that can pose a challenge for computing infrastructure. While in the genomics area, many applications can run on Linux nodes the situation in proteomics is different. In proteomics, many applications are optimized to run on Windows computer only. As a sci- entific service provider, a core facility needs reliable, reproducible and easy to use integrated solutions. Liquid chromatography mass spectrometry intensity based label-free quantifica- tion using data-dependent acquisition is a popular approach in proteomics to perform relative quantification of proteins in complex samples. MaxQuant is a widely used software for this type of analysis which has a complex graphical user interface and provides information-rich outputs. We run it in which also includes Scaffold for search result validation and visualization and an R based quality control report generation. Data analysis workflows consists of several components: a workflow engine, compute hosts, and archives. In particular, applications can run on compute hosts, while the data is kept in an archive server. Therefore, the input and output need to be staged to the compute host and the results need to be staged back to the archive. This complexity can be overwhelming for a most common user. These different components have all been integrated into a robust and user-friendly application to process standardized label-free quantification experiments. We integrated MaxQuant as an in-house Software as a Service application so it can be used by any workflow engine in a platform-independent manner. In this manuscript, we provide a technical description of how MaxQuant as software service has been integrated into our heterogeneous compute environment for reproducible and automatic large scale high throughput data processing of label-free quantification experiments. In this Pride dataset we provide four raw files along with the full MaxQuant results, the Scaffold file, the QC-pdf report to have a concrete idea of the potential of our workflow. These data are generated in the FGCZ-course in Nov. 2016 (for further information see: http://www.fgcz.ch/education/genomics-courses01.html).

Project description:BackgroundOnline health communities have given rise to a new e-service known as online medical consultations (OMCs), enabling remote interactions between physicians and patients. To address challenges, such as patient information overload and uneven distribution of physician visits, online health communities should develop OMC-oriented recommenders.ObjectiveWe aimed to comprehensively investigate what paradigms lead to the success of OMC-oriented recommendations.MethodsA literature search was conducted through e-databases, including PubMed, ACM Digital Library, Springer, and ScienceDirect, from January 2011 to December 2023. This review included all papers directly and indirectly related to the topic of health care-related recommendations for online services.ResultsThe search identified 611 articles, of which 26 (4.3%) met the inclusion criteria. Despite the growing academic interest in OMC recommendations, there remains a lack of consensus among researchers on the definition of e-service-oriented recommenders. The discussion highlighted 3 key factors influencing recommender success: features, algorithms, and metrics. It advocated for moving beyond traditional e-commerce-oriented recommenders to establish an innovative theoretical framework for e-service-oriented recommenders and addresses critical technical issues regarding 2-sided personalized recommendations.ConclusionsThis review underscores the essence of e-services, particularly in knowledge- and labor-intensive domains such as OMCs, where patients seek interpretable recommendations due to their lack of domain knowledge and physicians must balance their energy levels to avoid overworking. Our study's findings shed light on the importance of customizing e-service-oriented personalized recommendations to meet the distinct expectations of 2-sided users considering their cognitive abilities, decision-making perspectives, and preferences. To achieve this, a paradigm shift is essential to develop unique attributes and explore distinct content tailored for both parties involved.