Dataset Information

Public Preferences for Government Response Policies on Outbreak Control.

ABSTRACT:

Objective

The aim of this study was to assess the extent to which public support for outbreak containment policies varies with respect to the severity of an infectious disease outbreak.

Methods

A web-enabled survey was administered to 1017 residents of Singapore during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, and was quota-sampled based on age, sex, and ethnicity. A fractional-factorial design was used to create hypothetical outbreak vignettes characterised by morbidity and fatality rates, and local and global spread of an infectious disease. Each respondent was asked to indicate which response policies (among five policies restricting local movement and four border control policies) they would support in five randomly assigned vignettes. Binomial logistic regressions were used to predict the probabilities of support as a function of outbreak attributes, personal characteristics, and perceived policy effectiveness.

Results

Likelihood of support varied across government response policies but was generally higher for border control policies compared with internal policies. The fatality rate was the most important factor for internal policies, while the degree of global spread was the most important for border control policies. In general, individuals who were less healthy, had higher-income, and were older were more likely to support these policies. Perceived effectiveness of a policy was a consistent and positive predictor of public support.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that campaigns to promote public support should be designed specifically to each policy and tailored to different segments of the population. They should also be adapted based on the evolving conditions of the outbreak in order to receive continued public support.

SUBMITTER: Ozdemir S

PROVIDER: S-EPMC8035860 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:Background. Infectious diseases constitute a significant concern worldwide due to their increasing prevalence, associated health risks, and the socioeconomic costs. Machine learning (ML) models and epidemic models formulated using deterministic differential equations are the most dominant tools for analyzing and modeling the transmission of infectious diseases. However, ML models can be inconsistent in extracting the dynamics of a disease in the presence of data drifts. Likewise, the capability of epidemic models is constrained to parameter dimensions and estimation. We aimed at creating a framework of informed ML that integrates a random forest (RF) with an adapted susceptible infectious recovered (SIR) model to account for accuracy and consistency in stochasticity within the dynamics of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). Methods. An adapted SIR model was used to inform a default RF on predicting new COVID-19 cases (NCCs) at given intervals. We validated the performance of the informed RF (IRF) using real data. We used Botswana's pharmaceutical interventions (PIs) and non-PIs (NPIs) adopted between February 2020 and August 2022. The discrepancy between predictions and observations is modeled using loss functions, which are minimized, interpreted, and used to assess the IRF. Results. The findings on the real data have revealed the effectiveness of the default RF in modeling and predicting NCCs. The use of the effective reproductive rate to inform the RF yielded an excellent predictive power (84%) compared with 75% by the default RF. Conclusion. This research has potential to inform policy and decision makers in developing systems to evaluate interventions for infectious diseases.HighlightsThis framework is initiated by incorporating model outputs from an epidemic model to a machine learning model.An informed random forest (RF) is instantiated to model government and public responses to the COVID-19 pandemic.This framework does not require data transformations, and the epidemic model is shown to boost the RF's performance.This is a baseline knowledge-informed learning framework for assessing public health interventions in Botswana.