Dataset Information

Better sensitivity to linear and nonlinear trends with position than with color.

ABSTRACT: Useful data visualizations have the potential to leverage the visual system's natural abilities to process and summarize simple and complex information. Here, we tested whether the design recommendations made for pairwise comparisons generalize to the detection of trends. We created two different types of graphs: line graphs and stripplots. These graphs were created from identical datasets that simulated temperature changes across time. These datasets varied in the type of trend (linear and exponential). Human observers performed a trend detection task for which they judged whether the trend in temperature over time was increasing or decreasing. Participants were more sensitive to trend direction with line graphs compared to stripplots. Participants also demonstrated a systematic bias to respond that the trend was increasing for line graphs. However, this bias decreased with increasing sensitivity. Despite the better sensitivity to line graphs, more than half of the participants found the stripplots more appealing and liked them more than the line graphs. In conclusion, our results indicate that, for trend detection, depicting data with position (line graphs) leads to better performance compared to depicting graphs with color (stripplots). Yet, graphs with color (stripplots) were preferred over the line graphs, suggesting that there may be a tradeoff between the aesthetic design of the graphs and the precision in communicating the information.

SUBMITTER: Witt JK

PROVIDER: S-EPMC8131990 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:In vision science, cascades of Linear+Nonlinear transforms are very successful in modeling a number of perceptual experiences. However, the conventional literature is usually too focused on only describing the forward input-output transform. Instead, in this work we present the mathematics of such cascades beyond the forward transform, namely the Jacobian matrices and the inverse. The fundamental reason for this analytical treatment is that it offers useful analytical insight into the psychophysics, the physiology, and the function of the visual system. For instance, we show how the trends of the sensitivity (volume of the discrimination regions) and the adaptation of the receptive fields can be identified in the expression of the Jacobian w.r.t. the stimulus. This matrix also tells us which regions of the stimulus space are encoded more efficiently in multi-information terms. The Jacobian w.r.t. the parameters shows which aspects of the model have bigger impact in the response, and hence their relative relevance. The analytic inverse implies conditions for the response and model parameters to ensure appropriate decoding. From the experimental and applied perspective, (a) the Jacobian w.r.t. the stimulus is necessary in new experimental methods based on the synthesis of visual stimuli with interesting geometrical properties, (b) the Jacobian matrices w.r.t. the parameters are convenient to learn the model from classical experiments or alternative goal optimization, and (c) the inverse is a promising model-based alternative to blind machine-learning methods for neural decoding that do not include meaningful biological information. The theory is checked by building and testing a vision model that actually follows a modular Linear+Nonlinear program. Our illustrative derivable and invertible model consists of a cascade of modules that account for brightness, contrast, energy masking, and wavelet masking. To stress the generality of this modular setting we show examples where some of the canonical Divisive Normalization modules are substituted by equivalent modules such as the Wilson-Cowan interaction model (at the V1 cortex) or a tone-mapping model (at the retina).

Dataset Information

Better sensitivity to linear and nonlinear trends with position than with color.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets