Dataset Information

Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Fibrinolysis vs Thoracoscopic Decortication for Early Empyema.

ABSTRACT:

Background

Surgical decortication is recommended by national guidelines for management of early empyema, but intrapleural fibrinolysis is frequently used as a first-line therapy in clinical practice. This study compared the cost-effectiveness of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) decortication with intrapleural fibrinolysis for early empyema.

Methods

A decision analysis model was developed. The base clinical case was a 65-year-old man with early empyema treated either by VATS decortication or intrapleural tissue plasminogen activator and deoxyribonuclease. The likelihood of key outcomes occurring was derived from the literature. Medicare diagnosis-related groups and manufacturers' drug prices were used for cost estimates. Successful treatment was defined as complete or nearly complete resolution of empyema on imaging. Effectiveness was defined as health utility 1 year after empyema.

Results

Intrapleural tissue plasminogen activator and deoxyribonuclease were more cost-effective than VATS decortication for treating early empyema for the base clinical case. Surgical decortication had a slightly lower cost than fibrinolysis ($13,345 vs $13,965), but fibrinolysis had marginally higher effectiveness at 1 year (health utility of 0.80 vs 0.71). Therefore, fibrinolysis was the more cost-effective option. Sensitivity analyses found that fibrinolysis as the initial therapy was more cost-effective when the probability of success was greater than 60% or the initial cost was less than $13,000.

Conclusions

Surgical decortication and intrapleural fibrinolysis have nearly equivalent cost-effectiveness for early empyema in patients who can tolerate both procedures. Surgeons should consider patient-specific factors, as well as the cost and effectiveness of both modalities, when deciding on an initial treatment for early empyema.

SUBMITTER: Shipe ME

PROVIDER: S-EPMC8155089 | biostudies-literature | 2021 Nov

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Fibrinolysis vs Thoracoscopic Decortication for Early Empyema.

Shipe Maren E ME Maiga Amelia W AW Deppen Stephen A SA Haddad Diane N DN Gillaspie Erin A EA Maldonado Fabien F Kozower Benjamin D BD Grogan Eric L EL

The Annals of thoracic surgery 20201127 5

<h4>Background</h4>Surgical decortication is recommended by national guidelines for management of early empyema, but intrapleural fibrinolysis is frequently used as a first-line therapy in clinical practice. This study compared the cost-effectiveness of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) decortication with intrapleural fibrinolysis for early empyema.<h4>Methods</h4>A decision analysis model was developed. The base clinical case was a 65-year-old man with early empyema treated either by ...[more]

PMID: 33253674

Similar Datasets

Project description:PurposeManagement of empyema has been debated in the literature for decades. Although both primary video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) and tube thoracostomy with pleural instillation of fibrinolytics have been shown to result in early resolution when compared to tube thoracostomy alone, there is a lack of comparative data between these modes of management. Therefore, we conducted a prospective, randomized trial comparing VATS to fibrinolytic therapy in children with empyema.MethodsAfter Institutional Review Board approval, children defined as having empyema by either loculation on imaging or more than 10,000 white blood cells/microL were treated with VATS or fibrinolysis. Based on our retrospective data using length of postoperative hospitalization as the primary end point, a sample size of 36 patients was calculated for an alpha of .5 and a power of 0.8. Fibrinolysis consisted of inserting a 12F chest tube followed by infusion of 4 mg tissue plasminogen activator mixed with 40 mL of normal saline at the time of tube placement followed by 2 subsequent doses 24 hours apart.ResultsAt diagnosis, there were no differences between groups in age, weight, degree of oxygen support, white blood cell count, or days of symptoms. The outcome data showed no difference in days of hospitalization after intervention, days of oxygen requirement, days until afebrile, or analgesic requirements. Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery was associated with significantly higher charges. Three patients (16.6%) in the fibrinolysis group subsequently required VATS for definitive therapy. Two patients in the VATS group required ventilator support after therapy, one of whom required temporary dialysis. No patient in the fibrinolysis group clinically worsened after initiation of therapy.ConclusionsThere are no therapeutic or recovery advantages between VATS and fibrinolysis for the treatment of empyema; however, VATS resulted in significantly greater charges. Fibrinolysis may pose less risk of acute clinical deterioration and should be the first-line therapy for children with empyema.

Project description:BackgroundPrevious studies of decortication for empyema demonstrated that patient characteristics are associated with mortality, but the relationship of infectious pathogen to outcome has not been described. Our objective was to analyze the association of microbiology and antibiotic resistance with postoperative mortality after decortication for empyema. We hypothesized that bacterial pathogens, antibiotic resistance, and patient characteristics would all contribute to perioperative morbidity and mortality.MethodsPatients undergoing pulmonary decortication for empyema from January 1, 2010 to October 1, 2017 were reviewed retrospectively. Cases were matched with microbiology cultures. Outcomes of interest were a composite of death, tracheostomy, initial ventilator support greater than 48 hours, or unexpected intensive care unit readmission. Antibiotic resistance was categorized as present or absent, and the number of antibiotics with resistance was counted for each patient. We describe the relationship of patient characteristics, antibiotic resistance, and microbiology to mortality.ResultsDuring the study period, 185 patients underwent decortication, 118 of whom had a diagnosis of primary empyema (63.8%). Positive culture results were present in 79 of 185 patients (43%). The most common isolate was Streptococcus, which was present in 29 of 79 (37%), followed by Staphylococcus in 19 of 79 (24%). Of 79 patients, 11 had fungal infections (13.9%). In addition, 16 of 79 patients had polymicrobial empyema (20%). Of 185 patients, 30 experienced the composite adverse outcome (16.2%). In multivariable regression, the composite adverse outcome was associated with emphysema, Candida in pleural culture, and antibiotic resistance count.ConclusionsPerioperative mortality and morbidity after decortication for empyema is considerable. In this cohort, infections with increasing antibiotic resistance are associated with morbidity and mortality among patients with empyema.

Dataset Information

Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Fibrinolysis vs Thoracoscopic Decortication for Early Empyema.

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusions

Publications

Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Fibrinolysis vs Thoracoscopic Decortication for Early Empyema.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets