Dataset Information

Randomized Multi-Reader Evaluation of Automated Detection and Segmentation of Brain Tumors in Stereotactic Radiosurgery with Deep Neural Networks.

ABSTRACT:

Background

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS), a validated treatment for brain tumors, requires accurate tumor contouring. This manual segmentation process is time-consuming and prone to substantial inter-practitioner variability. Artificial intelligence (AI) with deep neural networks have increasingly been proposed for use in lesion detection and segmentation but have seldom been validated in a clinical setting.

Methods

We conducted a randomized, cross-modal, multi-reader, multi-specialty, multi-case study to evaluate the impact of AI assistance on brain tumor SRS. A state-of-the-art auto-contouring algorithm built on multi-modality imaging and ensemble neural networks was integrated into the clinical workflow. Nine medical professionals contoured the same case series in two reader modes (assisted or un-assisted) with a memory washout period of 6 weeks between each section. The case series consisted of ten algorithm-unseen cases, including five cases of brain metastases, three of meningiomas and two of acoustic neuromas. Among the nine readers, three experienced experts determined the ground truths of tumor contours.

Results

With the AI assistance, the inter-reader agreement significantly increased (Dice similarity coefficient [DSC] from 0.86 to 0.90, P<0.001). Algorithm-assisted physicians demonstrated a higher sensitivity for lesion detection than un-assisted physicians (91.3% versus 82.6%, P=0.030). AI assistance improved contouring accuracy, with an average increase in DSC of 0.028, especially for physicians with less SRS experience (average DSC from 0.847 to 0.865, P=0.002). In addition, AI assistance improved efficiency with a median of 30.8%-time savings. Less-experienced clinicians gained prominent improvement on contouring accuracy but less benefit in reduction of working hours. By contrast, SRS specialists had a relatively minor advantage in DSC, but greater timesaving with the aid of AI.

Conclusions

Deep learning neural networks can be optimally utilized to improve accuracy and efficiency for the clinical workflow in brain tumor SRS.

SUBMITTER: Lu SL

PROVIDER: S-EPMC8408868 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:PurposeTo develop a fast and accurate convolutional neural network based method for segmentation of thalamic nuclei.MethodsA cascaded multi-planar scheme with a modified residual U-Net architecture was used to segment thalamic nuclei on conventional and white-matter-nulled (WMn) magnetization prepared rapid gradient echo (MPRAGE) data. A single network was optimized to work with images from healthy controls and patients with multiple sclerosis (MS) and essential tremor (ET), acquired at both 3 T and 7 T field strengths. WMn-MPRAGE images were manually delineated by a trained neuroradiologist using the Morel histological atlas as a guide to generate reference ground truth labels. Dice similarity coefficient and volume similarity index (VSI) were used to evaluate performance. Clinical utility was demonstrated by applying this method to study the effect of MS on thalamic nuclei atrophy.ResultsSegmentation of each thalamus into twelve nuclei was achieved in under a minute. For 7 T WMn-MPRAGE, the proposed method outperforms current state-of-the-art on patients with ET with statistically significant improvements in Dice for five nuclei (increase in the range of 0.05-0.18) and VSI for four nuclei (increase in the range of 0.05-0.19), while performing comparably for healthy and MS subjects. Dice and VSI achieved using 7 T WMn-MPRAGE data are comparable to those using 3 T WMn-MPRAGE data. For conventional MPRAGE, the proposed method shows a statistically significant Dice improvement in the range of 0.14-0.63 over FreeSurfer for all nuclei and disease types. Effect of noise on network performance shows robustness to images with SNR as low as half the baseline SNR. Atrophy of four thalamic nuclei and whole thalamus was observed for MS patients compared to healthy control subjects, after controlling for the effect of parallel imaging, intracranial volume, gender, and age (p < 0.004).ConclusionThe proposed segmentation method is fast, accurate, performs well across disease types and field strengths, and shows great potential for improving our understanding of thalamic nuclei involvement in neurological diseases.

Project description:In this study, we developed a multi-scale Convolutional neural network based Automated hippocampal subfield Segmentation Toolbox (CAST) for automated segmentation of hippocampal subfields. Although training CAST required approximately three days on a single workstation with a high-quality GPU card, CAST can segment a new subject in less than 1 min even with GPU acceleration disabled, thus this method is more time efficient than current automated methods and manual segmentation. This toolbox is highly flexible with either a single modality or multiple modalities and can be easily set up to be trained with a researcher's unique data. A 3D multi-scale deep convolutional neural network is the key algorithm used in the toolbox. The main merit of multi-scale images is the capability to capture more global structural information from down-sampled images without dramatically increasing memory and computational burden. The original images capture more local information to refine the boundary between subfields. Residual learning is applied to alleviate the vanishing gradient problem and improve the performance with a deeper network. We applied CAST with the same settings on two datasets, one 7T dataset (the UMC dataset) with only the T2 image and one 3T dataset (the MNI dataset) with both T1 and T2 images available. The segmentation accuracy of both CAST and the state-of-the-art automated method ASHS, in terms of the dice similarity coefficient (DSC), were comparable. CAST significantly improved the reliability of segmenting small subfields, such as CA2, CA3, and the entorhinal cortex (ERC), in terms of the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). Both ASHS and manual segmentation process some subfields (e.g. CA2 and ERC) with high DSC values but low ICC values, consequently increasing the difficulty of judging segmentation quality. CAST produces very consistent DSC and ICC values, with a maximal discrepancy of 0.01 (DSC-ICC) across all subfields. The pre-trained model, source code, and settings for the CAST toolbox are publicly available.