Dataset Information

Diffusion MRI harmonization enables joint-analysis of multicentre data of patients with cerebral small vessel disease

ABSTRACT: Highlights • RISH harmonization is applicable to multicentre dMRI of elderly subjects with SVD.• Harmonization removes site-differences in dMRI metrics in matched controls.• Associations between dMRI metrics and SVD markers in patients are preserved.• Harmonized scans can be pooled to into a single large dataset to increased power.

Objectives

Acquisition-related differences in diffusion magnetic resonance imaging (dMRI) hamper pooling of multicentre data to achieve large sample sizes. A promising solution is to harmonize the raw diffusion signal using rotation invariant spherical harmonic (RISH) features, but this has not been tested in elderly subjects. Here we aimed to establish if RISH harmonization effectively removes acquisition-related differences in multicentre dMRI of elderly subjects with cerebral small vessel disease (SVD), while preserving sensitivity to disease effects.

Methods

Five cohorts of patients with SVD (N = 397) and elderly controls (N = 175) with 3 Tesla MRI on different systems were included. First, to establish effectiveness of harmonization, the RISH method was trained with data of 13 to 15 age and sex-matched controls from each site. Fractional anisotropy (FA) and mean diffusivity (MD) were compared in matched controls between sites using tract-based spatial statistics (TBSS) and voxel-wise analysis, before and after harmonization. Second, to assess sensitivity to disease effects, we examined whether the contrast (effect sizes of FA, MD and peak width of skeletonized MD - PSMD) between patients and controls within each site remained unaffected by harmonization. Finally, we evaluated the association between white matter hyperintensity (WMH) burden, FA, MD and PSMD using linear regression analyses both within individual cohorts as well as with pooled scans from multiple sites, before and after harmonization.

Results

Before harmonization, significant differences in FA and MD were observed between matched controls of different sites (p < 0.05). After harmonization these site-differences were removed. Within each site, RISH harmonization did not alter the effect sizes of FA, MD and PSMD between patients and controls (relative change in Cohen’s d = 4 %) nor the strength of association with WMH volume (relative change in R2 = 2.8 %). After harmonization, patient data of all sites could be aggregated in a single analysis to infer the association between WMH volume and FA (R2 = 0.62), MD (R2 = 0.64), and PSMD (R2 = 0.60).

Conclusions

We showed that RISH harmonization effectively removes acquisition-related differences in dMRI of elderly subjects while preserving sensitivity to SVD-related effects. This study provides proof of concept for future multicentre SVD studies with pooled datasets.

SUBMITTER: de Brito Robalo B

PROVIDER: S-EPMC8609094 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:IntroductionThresholding of low-weight connections of diffusion MRI-based brain networks has been proposed to remove false-positive connections. It has been previously established that this yields more reproducible scan-rescan network architecture in healthy subjects. In patients with brain disease, network measures are applied to assess inter-individual variation and changes over time. Our aim was to investigate whether thresholding also achieves improved consistency in network architecture in patients, while maintaining sensitivity to disease effects for these applications.MethodsWe applied fixed-density and absolute thresholding on brain networks in patients with cerebral small vessel disease (SVD, n = 86; ≈24 months follow-up), as a clinically relevant exemplar condition. In parallel, we applied the same methods in healthy young subjects (n = 44; scan-rescan interval ≈4 months) as a frame of reference. Consistency of network architecture was assessed with dice similarity of edges and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) of edge-weights and hub-scores. Sensitivity to disease effects in patients was assessed by evaluating interindividual variation, changes over time, and differences between those with high and low white matter hyperintensity burden, using correlation analyses and mixed ANOVA.ResultsCompared to unthresholded networks, both thresholding methods generated more consistent architecture over time in patients (unthresholded: dice = .70; ICC: .70-.78; thresholded: dice = .77; ICC: .73-.83). However, absolute thresholding created fragmented nodes. Similar observations were made in the reference group. Regarding sensitivity to disease effects in patients, fixed-density thresholds that were optimal in terms of consistency (densities: .10-.30) preserved interindividual variation in global efficiency and node strength as well as the sensitivity to detect effects of time and group. Absolute thresholding produced larger fluctuations of interindividual variation.ConclusionsOur results indicate that thresholding of low-weight connections, particularly when using fixed-density thresholding, results in more consistent network architecture in patients with longer rescan intervals, while preserving sensitivity to disease effects.

Project description:Even with postmortem pathological examination, only limited information is provided of the foci of in vivo clinical information. Cerebral small vessel disease, which is associated with ageing, dementia and stroke, highlights the difficulty in arriving at a definitive diagnosis of the lesions detected on in vivo radiological examination. We performed a radiological-pathological comparative study using ex vivo MRI to examine small cerebral lesions. Four patients with small vessel disease lesions detected on in vivo MRI were studied. Exact pathological findings of in vivo MRI-detected lesions were revealed. The ischaemic lesion after 17 days from onset showed positivity for peroxiredoxin, cluster of differentiation 204 and glial fibrillary acidic protein, indicating sterile inflammation and neuroprotective reaction. Cortical microinfarcts beneath the cortical superficial siderosis were associated with inflammation from the superficial layer in a patient with cerebral amyloid angiopathy; in this patient, a bilinear track-like appearance of the cortical superficial siderosis on the ex vivo MRI was compatible with iron deposition on the pia matter and within cortical layers II-III. An in vivo MRI-detected cerebral microbleed was revealed to be heterogeneous. An in vivo MRI-detected cerebral microbleed was revealed to be a venous angioma. Furthermore, a neuropathologically confirmed embolic cerebral microbleed was firstly detected using this method. Our results suggest that in vivo MRI-detected lobar cerebral microbleeds can be caused by non-cerebral amyloid angiopathy aetiologies, such as microembolism and venous angioma. Venous angioma and embolic microbleeds may mimic cerebral amyloid angiopathy markers on in vivo MRI. To clarify the clinical importance of these lesions, we should investigate their rate and frequency in a large cohort of healthy individuals and patients with cardiac risk factors. Thus, we provide evidence that ex vivo micro-MRI improves the clinical diagnosis of small vessel diseases.