Dataset Information

The effect of interventions anticipated to improve plantar intrinsic foot muscle strength on fall-related dynamic function in adults: a systematic review.

ABSTRACT:

Background

The plantar intrinsic foot muscles (PIFMs) have a role in dynamic functions, such as balance and propulsion, which are vital to walking. These muscles atrophy in older adults and therefore this population, which is at high risk to falling, may benefit from strengthening these muscles in order to improve or retain their gait performance. Therefore, the aim was to provide insight in the evidence for the effect of interventions anticipated to improve PIFM strength on dynamic balance control and foot function during gait in adults.

Methods

A systematic literature search was performed in five electronic databases. The eligibility of peer-reviewed papers, published between January 1, 2010 and July 8, 2020, reporting controlled trials and pre-post interventional studies was assessed by two reviewers independently. Results from moderate- and high-quality studies were extracted for data synthesis by summarizing the standardized mean differences (SMD). The GRADE approach was used to assess the certainty of evidence.

Results

Screening of 9199 records resulted in the inclusion of 11 articles of which five were included for data synthesis. Included studies were mainly performed in younger populations. Low-certainty evidence revealed the beneficial effect of PIFM strengthening exercises on vertical ground reaction force (SMD: - 0.31-0.37). Very low-certainty evidence showed that PIFM strength training improved the performance on dynamic balance testing (SMD: 0.41-1.43). There was no evidence for the effect of PIFM strengthening exercises on medial longitudinal foot arch kinematics.

Conclusions

This review revealed at best low-certainty evidence that PIFM strengthening exercises improve foot function during gait and very low-certainty evidence for its favorable effect on dynamic balance control. There is a need for high-quality studies that aim to investigate the effect of functional PIFM strengthening exercises in large samples of older adults. The outcome measures should be related to both fall risk and the role of the PIFMs such as propulsive forces and balance during locomotion in addition to PIFM strength measures.

SUBMITTER: Willemse L

PROVIDER: S-EPMC8772142 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:Human plantar intrinsic foot muscles consist of 10 muscles that originate and insert within the sole of the foot. It is known that the anatomical cross-sectional area (ACSA) and muscle thickness of two plantar intrinsic foot muscles, the flexor hallucis brevis (FHB) and abductor hallucis (ABH), associate with morphological parameters of the foot, such as total and truncated foot length and navicular height. However, it is unclear how the size for each of the plantar intrinsic foot muscles associates with various morphological profiles of the foot. This study aimed to elucidate this subject. By using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), serial images of the right foot were obtained in 13 young adult men without foot deformities. From the obtained MR images, ACSA for each of the individual plantar intrinsic foot muscles was analyzed along the foot length, and then its muscle volume (MV) was calculated. The analyzed muscles were the abductor digiti minimi (ABDM), ABH, adductor hallucis oblique head (ADDH-OH), adductor hallucis transverse head (ADDH-TH), flexor digitorum brevis (FDB), FHB, and quadratus plantae (QP). Furthermore, MV of the whole plantar intrinsic foot muscle (WHOLE) was defined as the total MVs of all the analyzed muscles. As morphological parameters, total foot length, truncated foot length, forefoot width, ball circumference, instep circumference, navicular height, great toe eversion angle, and little toe inversion angle were measured using a laser three-dimensional foot scanner in standing and sitting conditions. In addition, navicular drop (ND) and normalized truncated navicular height (NTNH) were also calculated as medial longitudinal arch (MLA) height indices. The MV of WHOLE was significantly associated with the forefoot width, ball circumference, and instep circumference (r = 0.647-0.711, p = 0.006-0.013). Positive correlations were found between the forefoot width and MV of FHB, FDB, and QP (r = 0.564-0.653, p = 0.015-0.045), between the ball circumference and MV of QP (r = 0.559, p = 0.047), between the instep circumference and MV of FHB (r = 0.609, p = 0.027), and between the little toe inversion angle and MV of QP (r = 0.570, p = 0.042). The MVs of ABH, ABDM, and ADDH-OH were not significantly correlated with any morphological parameters of the foot. Similarly, no significant correlations were found between MV of each muscle and either of the MLA height indices (ND and NTNH). Thus, the current results indicate that forefoot width and circumferential parameters (instep and ball circumference), not MLA height, associate with the size of the whole plantar intrinsic foot muscles, especially those specialized in toe flexion (FHB, FDB, and QP).

Project description:IntroductionDiabetes mellitus (DM) is associated with hyperglycaemia and advanced glycosylation end-products. In the foot, the consequences of chronic or uncontrolled diabetes are micro and macrovascular disease, neuropathy, reduced joint mobility and structural and soft tissue changes that increase the risk of ulcer development and amputation. Diabetes foot assessment currently includes a comprehensive history, neurological and vascular assessments and examination focussed on dermatological and musculoskeletal abnormalities. Whilst these assessments are helpful for predicting ulceration risk, direct identifiers that enable early therapeutic intervention are lacking. The intention of this review was to ascertain if B-mode ultrasound could be clinically applied to identify structural change in the diabetic foot and be utilised as an early predictor of ulceration risk.MethodsPrimary databases and grey literature sources were systematically searched. Selection criteria were that the study included a diabetic sample and used B-mode ultrasound to assess soft tissue structures of the foot (plantar skin, plantar fat pad or intrinsic muscles).ResultsFifteen studies were identified for inclusion (combined diabetic sample of 773). Ultrasound demonstrated reductions in tissue thickness in diabetics compared to non-diabetics under first (p = 0.01) and second (p = 0.03) metatarsal heads, but not the third (p = 0.24). Statistical heterogeneity was high for ultrasound thickness measures under metatarsal heads four/five (I2 65%, 81%) and very high for plantar skin (I2 98%), heel pad (I2 76%) and intrinsic muscles (I2 91%, 81%). Extensor digitorum brevis (EDB) ultrasound measures were significantly thinner in diabetics for all dimension measures compared to healthy controls except one study, which reported no significant differences in EDB thickness.ConclusionsNo direct evidence was found to indicate B-mode ultrasound measures can predict soft tissue changes in the plantar foot in diabetes, although low level studies indicate ultrasound has the potential to identify structural change. Clinical, methodological and statistical heterogeneity limit result applicability. This review highlights the need for robust prospective longitudinal research to examine the predictive validity of this method.

Project description:Highlights • Metatarsalphalangeal joint quasi-stiffness during jumping was reduced by the application of a selective tibial nerve block, which removed the active contributions of the intrinsic foot muscles• When jumping under the nerve block, ankle leverage and torque were reduced when compared to normal conditions• Fascicle and muscle–tendon unit velocity were not different during jumping propulsion between normal and nerve block conditions• Although impulse was similar between conditions, jump height was reduced under the nerve block condition due to a lower take-off position of the center of mass Background During human locomotion, a sufficiently stiff foot allows the ankle plantar flexors to generate large propulsive powers. Increasing foot stiffness (e.g., via a carbon plate) increases the ankle's external moment arm in relation to the internal moment arm (i.e., increasing gear ratio), reduces plantar flexor muscles’ shortening velocity, and enhances muscle force production. In contrast, when activation of the foot's intrinsic muscles is impaired, there is a reduction in foot and ankle work and metatarsophalangeal joint stiffness. We speculated that the reduced capacity to actively control metatarsophalangeal joint stiffness may impair the gearing function of the foot at the ankle. Methods We used a tibial nerve block to examine the direct effects of the intrinsic foot muscles on ankle joint kinetics, in vivo medial gastrocnemius’ musculotendinous dynamics, and ankle gear ratio on 14 participants during maximal vertical jumping. Results Under the nerve block, the internal ankle plantar flexion moment decreased (p = 0.004) alongside a reduction in external moment arm length (p = 0.021) and ankle joint gear ratio (p = 0.049) when compared to the non-blocked condition. Although medial gastrocnemius muscle–tendon unit and fascicle velocity were not different between conditions, the Achilles tendon was shorter during propulsion in the nerve block condition (p < 0.001). Conclusion In addition to their known role of regulating the energetic function of the foot, our data indicate that the intrinsic foot muscles also act to optimize ankle joint torque production and leverage during the propulsion phase of vertical jumping. Graphical Abstract Image, graphical abstract