Dataset Information

Do norms unintentionally increase stereotypical expressions? A randomised controlled trial.

ABSTRACT:

Introduction

Implicit biases of health professionals could cause biased judgements. Many anti-bias interventions seem to be ineffective, and some even counterproductive. People tend to be compliant to standards describing what the majority of people finds or does, and this could cause people to think in a stereotype-consistent manner. This study examines whether descriptive social norms such as 'the majority of people have stereotypes' (majority message), as often stated in interventions, actually increase people's stereotypes. To examine the effect of descriptive social norms (Hypothesis 1) and the effect of individual perceptions and preferences (Hypothesis 2a and 2b) on stereotypical expressions towards medical students.

Methods

First, we determined which ethic stereotypes regarding medical students prevail in Dutch medical education (N = 52). Next, two similar randomised controlled trials, both with teachers and students, were carried out (N = 158 and N = 123, respectively), one with an East Asian student picture (ethnic minority) and one with a native Dutch student picture (ethnic majority). Participants were randomly assigned to either a majority-message, minority-message or no-message condition, and rated the presented minority or majority picture on specific stereotypical features. Subsequently, participants described a typical day of that same student's life. These descriptions were rated for stereotypicality by two independent raters, who were blind for condition and stimulus. Inclusive work environment (IWC) and social dominance orientation (SDO) of participants were measured as indicators of individual perceptions and preferences.

Results

Stereotypes were expressed towards both picture stimuli, yet message condition did not affect stereotypical expressions. SDO positively related to stereotypical expressions towards the East Asian student, whereas IWC positively related to stereotypical expressions towards the native Dutch student.

Conclusion

Interventions do not unintentionally increase stereotypes by communicating what the majority of people thinks or does. Individual perceptions and preferences are predictive of stereotypes, whereas descriptive social norms are not.

SUBMITTER: van Andel CEE

PROVIDER: S-EPMC9304281 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:BackgroundThe exact extent of and the mechanism by which trastuzumab causes cardiac side effects are not completely unravelled. We investigated the (cardiotoxic) side effects of trastuzumab in a relatively large homogeneous population.MethodsHealthy male volunteers (n = 54) with a left ventricle ejection fraction (LVEF) > 55% were administered 6 mg/kg trastuzumab (n = 46) IV in 90 min in a placebo-controlled, parallel study. Placebo consisted of 0 · 9% NaCl (n = 8). Assessments included body weight, routine and cardiac laboratory markers and serial echocardiographic examinations (8 placebo and 9 trastuzumab treated participants) up to 63 days after dosing. Statistical analysis was done using repeated measurements of variance.FindingsFollowing trastuzumab infusion, fluid retention was observed: mean body weight increased over the first 4 days post-administration with 0 · 4 kg (95%-confidence interval: - 0 · 2, 0 · 9, p = 0 · 2261) compared to placebo, mean haemoglobin concentration decreased with 0 · 3 mM (- 0 · 6, - 0 · 1; p = 0 · 0043), as did haematocrit (- 0 · 013 L/L [- 0 · 024, - 0 · 002], p = 0 · 0216), and protein (- 2 g/L [- 4, - 0], p = 0 · 0443) and albumin (- 2 g/L [- 3, - 1], p < 0 · 0001) concentrations. Elevations in NT-proBNP levels, parallel to the weight increase, were observed in individual cases, but not on a group level. Troponin-T concentrations did not increase. The only echocardiographic parameter that changed significantly at all studied dose levels was E/A-ratio, a load-dependent parameter: from 1 · 81 (SD 0 · 42) to 1 · 98 (0 · 31) 3-5 days after administration, contrast to placebo of 0 · 57 (90%-CI: 0 · 21-0 · 93, p = 0 · 0034). Ejection fraction and pulsed-wave Doppler recorded parameters remained unchanged.InterpretationSingle dose administration of trastuzumab in humans is associated with an immediate, transient extracellular volume increase, either as a primary or secondary (compensatory) response, which can be detected easily using routine clinical assessments. Echocardiographic changes, both short and long term, could not be found after single dose administration to drug-naive patients.

Project description:To address uncertainties prior to conducting a fully powered randomised controlled trial of Morita Therapy plus treatment as usual (TAU) versus TAU alone, or to determine that such a trial is not appropriate and/or feasible.Pilot parallel group randomised controlled feasibility trial.Participants aged ?18 years with Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM)-IV major depressive disorder, with or without DSM-IV anxiety disorder(s), recruited from general practice record searches in Devon, UK.We randomised participants on a 1:1 basis stratified by symptom severity, concealing allocation using a secure independent web-based system, to receive TAU (control) or 8-12 sessions of Morita Therapy, a Japanese psychological therapy, plus TAU (intervention).Rates of recruitment, retention and treatment adherence; variance and estimated between-group differences in follow-up scores (on the Patient Health Questionnaire 9 (PHQ-9) (depressive symptoms); Generalised Anxiety Disorder Questionnaire 7 (anxiety symptoms); Short Form 36 Health Survey Questionnaire/Work and Social Adjustment Scale (quality of life); Morita Attitudinal Scale for Arugamama (attitudes)) and their correlation with baseline scores.We recruited 68 participants, 5.1% (95% CI 3.4% to 6.6%) of those invited (34 control; 34 intervention); 64/68 (94%; 95% CI 88.3% to 99.7%) provided 4-month follow-up data. Participants had a mean age of 49 years and mean PHQ-9 score of 16.8; 61% were female. Twenty-four of 34 (70.6%) adhered to the minimum treatment dose. The follow-up PHQ-9 (future primary outcome measure) pooled SD was 6.4 (95% CI 5.5 to 7.8); the magnitude of correlation between baseline and follow-up PHQ-9 scores was 0.42 (95% CI 0.19 to 0.61). Of the participants, 66.7% and 30.0% recovered in the intervention and control groups, respectively; 66.7% and 13.3% responded to treatment in the intervention and control groups, respectively.A large-scale trial of Morita Therapy would require 133 participants per group and is feasible with minor modifications to the pilot trial protocol. Morita Therapy shows promise in treating depression and may provide patients with a distinct alternative to current treatments.ISRCTN17544090; Pre-results.