Comparative Analyses: Expression Differences for Repair Tissue, Chondrocytes, and Mesenchymal Stromal Cells

ABSTRACT: Previous studies have demonstrated relative deficiencies of repair tissue within articular lesions when compared to articular cartilage. While cells occupying the lesions might be of mesenchymal origin, they do not recapitulate differentiation to the chondrogenic phenotype of normal articular chondrocytes. Nevertheless, attributes of repair tissue appear similar to chondrocytes and their precursors at various other different states. We hypothesized that analyses of gene expression profiles for these other cell phenotypes would elucidate the identity of repair tissue cells. Total RNA was isolated from repair tissue samples, neonatal articular cartilage, primary articular chondrocytes maintained in monolayer culture and passaged weekly over 28 days, and bone marrow stromal cells expanded to 80% confluence in monolayer culture. Total RNA was linearly amplified and applied to a 9413-probe set equine-specific cDNA microarray. Four repair tissue samples were compared with a dye-swap experimental design to four samples from each of the three other cell populations for a total of twelve comparisons, or twenty-four slides. Differential expression of genes of interest was validated by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction. Statistical analysis revealed that a total of 934 (9.9%), 1839 (19.5%), and 940 (10.0%) probe sets were differentially expressed for the bone marrow stromal cells versus repair tissue, de-differentiated chondrocytes versus repair tissue, and neonatal articular chondrocytes versus repair tissue comparisons, respectively. Transcriptional and translational machinery gene ontological categories were over-represented in transcripts demonstrating stable expression amongst the three comparisons. Biomarkers typically associated with normal articular cartilage and fibrocartilage repair tissue comprised much of the genes with the greatest levels of differential expression amongst the three comparisons. Overall, the profiles indicated that repair cells were more chondrogenic than bone marrow stromal cells and de-differentiated chondrocytes. However, transcript levels of key biomarkers and growth factors for repair tissue cells four months post-operatively fell far short of those of neonatal articular chondrocytes destined to undergo normal cartilage maturation.

ORGANISM(S): Equus caballus

PROVIDER: GSE14252 | GEO | 2010/03/30

SECONDARY ACCESSION(S): PRJNA111323

REPOSITORIES: GEO