Topologically Associating Domain Boundaries are Required for Normal Genome Function
Ontology highlight
ABSTRACT: Large-scale reaarangements and/or disruption of the three dimensional organization of the mammalian genome has been shown to cause develomental phenotypes. However, the functional requirement of TAD boundaries alone in development and disease remains an outstanding question in the field. Here, we show that TAD boundaries are required for the functional integrity of the genome in vivo. Using systematic genome-wide selection criteria and CRISPR/Cas9 editing, we deleted eight individual TAD boundaries ranging between 11-80 kb in size and investigated the in vivo consequences comprehensively by assessing survival, chromatin interaction data, gene expression and detailed phenotypic characterization. A majority of boundary deletions resulted in altered chromatin interactions, and/or multiple boundary deletions causing reduced embryonic survival or other developmental phenotypes. Our results elucidate the functional requirement of TAD boundary integrity in development and suggest that TAD bondary deletion may be sufficient to cause developmental phenotypes.
Project description:The genome is partitioned into Topologically Associating Domains (TADs). About half of the boundaries of these TADs exhibit transcriptional activity and are correlated with better TAD insulation. However, the association between these transcripts and TAD insulation, enhancer:promoter interactions and transcription of genes remains unknown. Here we investigate the functional roles of these bRNAs (boundary-RNA) in boundary insulation and consequent effects on enhancer-promoter interactions and TAD transcription genome-wide and more specifically on the disease relevant INK4a/ARF TAD. Using a series of CTCF site deletions and bRNA knockdown experiments at this TAD boundary, we show a direct association of CTCF with the bidirectional bRNAs where the loss of bRNA triggers the concomitant loss of: CTCF at the TAD boundary, its insulation, enhancer:promoter interactions and gene transcription within the targeted TAD. We used another series of enhancer deletions and CRISPRi on promoters within INK4a/ARF TAD to better understand the regulation and origins of bRNA itself. We observe that the enhancers interact with boundaries and positively regulate the bRNA transcription at TAD boundaries. In return, the bRNAs recruit/stabilize the CTCF even on weak motifs within these boundaries and supports CTCF binding in clusters, therefore enhancing TAD insulation. This favors the intra-TAD enhancer:promoter interactions and leads to robust gene transcription. Functionally, bRNAs are more stable than eRNAs and their knockdown exactly mimics the CTCF site deletion. Furthermore, transcribing boundaries exhibit high TAD transcription in TCGA tumour datasets. Together, these results show that active enhancers directly mediate better insulation of TADs by activating the transcription at TAD boundaries triggering CTCF clustering at the boundary which results in better insulation and favours robust intra-TAD enhancer:promoter interactions to activate the gene transcription.
Project description:Topological associating domains (TADs) are self-interacting genomic units crucial for shaping gene regulation patterns. Despite their importance, the extent of their evolutionary conservation and its functional implications remain largely unknown. In this study, we generate Hi-C and ChIP-seq data and compare TAD organization across four primate and four rodent species, and characterize the genetic and epigenetic properties of TAD boundaries in correspondence to their evolutionary conservation. We find 14% of all human TAD boundaries to be shared among all eight species (ultraconserved), while 15% are human-specific. Ultraconserved TAD boundaries have stronger insulation strength, CTCF binding, and enrichment of older retrotransposons, compared to species-specific boundaries. CRISPR-Cas9 knockouts of two ultraconserved boundaries in mouse models leads to tissue-specific gene expression changes and morphological phenotypes. Deletion of a human-specific boundary near the autism-related AUTS2 gene results in upregulation of this gene in neurons. Overall, our study provides pertinent TAD boundary evolutionary conservation annotations, and showcase the functional importance of TAD evolution.
Project description:Mechanisms establishing higher-order chromosome structures and their roles in gene regulation are elusive. We analyzed chromosome architecture during nematode X-chromosome dosage compensation, which represses transcription via a dosage-compensation condensin complex (DCC) that binds hermaphrodite Xs and establishes megabase-size topologically associating domains (TADs). We show that DCC binding at high-occupancy sites (rex sites) defines eight TAD boundary locations. Single rex deletions disrupted boundaries, and single insertions created new boundaries, demonstrating one rex site is necessary and sufficient for DCC-dependent boundary formation. Deleting eight rex sites (8rexΔ) recapitulated TAD structure of DCC mutants, permitting analysis when chromosome-wide domain architecture was disrupted but most DCC binding remained. 8rexΔ animals exhibited no changes in X expression and lacked dosage-compensation mutant phenotypes. Hence, TAD boundaries are neither the cause nor consequence of gene repression during dosage compensation. Abrogating TAD structure did, however, reduce thermotolerance, accelerate aging, and shorten lifespan, implicating chromosome architecture in regulating stress responses and aging.
Project description:Mechanisms establishing higher-order chromosome structures and their roles in gene regulation are elusive. We analyzed chromosome architecture during nematode X-chromosome dosage compensation, which represses transcription via a dosage-compensation condensin complex (DCC) that binds hermaphrodite Xs and establishes megabase-size topologically associating domains (TADs). We show that DCC binding at high-occupancy sites (rex sites) defines eight TAD boundary locations. Single rex deletions disrupted boundaries, and single insertions created new boundaries, demonstrating one rex site is necessary and sufficient for DCC-dependent boundary formation. Deleting eight rex sites (8rexΔ) recapitulated TAD structure of DCC mutants, permitting analysis when chromosome-wide domain architecture was disrupted but most DCC binding remained. 8rexΔ animals exhibited no changes in X expression and lacked dosage-compensation mutant phenotypes. Hence, TAD boundaries are neither the cause nor consequence of gene repression during dosage compensation. Abrogating TAD structure did, however, reduce thermotolerance, accelerate aging, and shorten lifespan, implicating chromosome architecture in regulating stress responses and aging.
Project description:Mechanisms establishing higher-order chromosome structures and their roles in gene regulation are elusive. We analyzed chromosome architecture during nematode X-chromosome dosage compensation, which represses transcription via a dosage-compensation condensin complex (DCC) that binds hermaphrodite Xs and establishes megabase-size topologically associating domains (TADs). We show that DCC binding at high-occupancy sites (rex sites) defines eight TAD boundary locations. Single rex deletions disrupted boundaries, and single insertions created new boundaries, demonstrating one rex site is necessary and sufficient for DCC-dependent boundary formation. Deleting eight rex sites (8rexΔ) recapitulated TAD structure of DCC mutants, permitting analysis when chromosome-wide domain architecture was disrupted but most DCC binding remained. 8rexΔ animals exhibited no changes in X expression and lacked dosage-compensation mutant phenotypes. Hence, TAD boundaries are neither the cause nor consequence of gene repression during dosage compensation. Abrogating TAD structure did, however, reduce thermotolerance, accelerate aging, and shorten lifespan, implicating chromosome architecture in regulating stress responses and aging.
Project description:Topologically Associating Domains (TADs) have been proposed to both guide and constrain enhancer activity. Shh is located within a TAD known to contain all its enhancers. To investigate the importance of chromatin conformation and TAD integrity on developmental gene regulation, we have manipulated the Shh TAD – creating internal deletions, deleting CTCF sites, and deleting and inverting sequences at TAD boundaries. Chromosome conformation capture and fluorescence in situ hybridisation assays were used to investigate the changes in chromatin conformation that result from these manipulations. Our data suggest that these substantial alterations in TAD structure has no readily detectable effect on Shh expression patterns during development – except where enhancers are deleted - and results in no detectable phenotypes. Only in the case of a larger deletion of one TAD boundary could ectopic influence of the Shh limb enhancer be detected on a gene (Mnx1) in the neighbouring TAD. Our data suggests that, contrary to expectations, the developmental regulation of Shh expression is remarkably robust to TAD perturbations.
Project description:Vertebrate genomes organize into topologically associating domains (TADs), delimited by boundaries that insulate regulatory elements from non-target genes. However, how boundary function is established is not well understood. Here, we combine genome-wide analyses and transgenic mouse assays to dissect the regulatory logic of clustered-CTCF boundaries in vivo, interrogating their function at multiple levels: chromatin interactions, transcription and phenotypes. Individual CTCF binding sites (CBS) deletions revealed that the characteristics of specific sites can outweigh other factors like CBS number and orientation. Combined deletions demonstrated that CBS cooperate redundantly and provide boundary robustness. We show that divergent CBS signatures are not strictly required for effective insulation and that chromatin loops can be formed by non-canonically oriented sites, which suggests a loop interference mechanism. Further, we observe that insulation strength constitutes an effective modulator of gene expression and phenotypes. Our results highlight the modular nature of boundaries and their control over developmental processes.
Project description:Vertebrate genomes organize into topologically associating domains (TADs), delimited by boundaries that insulate regulatory elements from non-target genes. However, how boundary function is established is not well understood. Here, we combine genome-wide analyses and transgenic mouse assays to dissect the regulatory logic of clustered-CTCF boundaries in vivo, interrogating their function at multiple levels: chromatin interactions, transcription and phenotypes. Individual CTCF binding sites (CBS) deletions revealed that the characteristics of specific sites can outweigh other factors like CBS number and orientation. Combined deletions demonstrated that CBS cooperate redundantly and provide boundary robustness. We show that divergent CBS signatures are not strictly required for effective insulation and that chromatin loops can be formed by non-canonically oriented sites, which suggests a loop interference mechanism. Further, we observe that insulation strength constitutes an effective modulator of gene expression and phenotypes. Our results highlight the modular nature of boundaries and their control over developmental processes.
Project description:Vertebrate genomes organize into topologically associating domains (TADs), delimited by boundaries that insulate regulatory elements from non-target genes. However, how boundary function is established is not well understood. Here, we combine genome-wide analyses and transgenic mouse assays to dissect the regulatory logic of clustered-CTCF boundaries in vivo, interrogating their function at multiple levels: chromatin interactions, transcription and phenotypes. Individual CTCF binding sites (CBS) deletions revealed that the characteristics of specific sites can outweigh other factors like CBS number and orientation. Combined deletions demonstrated that CBS cooperate redundantly and provide boundary robustness. We show that divergent CBS signatures are not strictly required for effective insulation and that chromatin loops can be formed by non-canonically oriented sites, which suggests a loop interference mechanism. Further, we observe that insulation strength constitutes an effective modulator of gene expression and phenotypes. Our results highlight the modular nature of boundaries and their control over developmental processes.
Project description:Mammalian genomes are organized into megabase-scale topologically associated domains (TADs) that have been proposed to represent large regulatory units. Here we demonstrate that disruption of TADs can cause rewiring of long-range regulatory architecture and result in pathogenic phenotypes. We show that distinct human limb malformations are caused by deletions, inversions, or duplications altering the structure of the TAD-spanning WNT6/IHH/EPHA4/PAX3 locus. Using CRISPR/Cas genome editing, we generated mice with corresponding rearrangements. Both in mouse limb tissue and patient-derived fibroblasts, disease-relevant structural changes cause ectopic interactions between promoters and non-coding DNA, and a cluster of limb enhancers normally associated with Epha4 is misplaced relative to TAD boundaries and drives ectopic limb expression of another gene in the locus. Our results demonstrate the functional importance of TADs for orchestrating gene expression via genome architecture and indicate criteria for predicting the pathogenicity of human structural variants, particularly in non-coding regions of the human genome. RNA-seq profile of developing distal limbs of mutants and WT animals at E11.5