Temporal dynamics of signaling and transcription underlying early adaptation to oncogenic BRAF inhibition in melanoma
Ontology highlight
ABSTRACT: Despite the recent remarkable progress of targeted therapies for the clinical management of many cancers, response rates remain lower than desired and long-term response durability is often poor due to drug resistance. A major contributor to treatment failure is drug-induced cellular adaptation to therapy, whereby systems-level reprogramming permits a drug-tolerant phenotype that may gradually lead to cell cycle re-entry and portend relapse. Drug adaptation is known to rapidly implicate complex signaling and transcriptional regulatory networks, but the scale and temporal dynamics of these remodeling events have yet to be fully resolved. Here, we used mass spectrometry-based phosphoproteomics and RNA sequencing to capture molecular snapshots within the first minutes, hours, and days of BRAF kinase inhibitor exposure in a drug-tolerant human BRAF-mutant melanoma model. By enriching specific phospho-motifs associated with mitogenic kinases, we were able to detect and monitor thousands of protein phosphorylation sites over a three-day period of drug treatment, followed by a six-day drug holiday to characterize the plasticity of the adaptive response. We observed early and sustained inhibition of the BRAF-ERK axis, gradual downregulation of canonical cell cycle-dependent phosphorylation events, and a clear delineation between three distinct phase transitions toward drug tolerance, which was almost completely reversible following drug removal. Through measuring the time evolution of large-scale networks, we were able to exploit phosphoproteome and transcriptome dynamics to infer kinetically-defined regulatory modules, revealing a concerted response to oncogenic BRAF inhibition involving cellular metabolism, RNA processing, and mitogenic signaling that demonstrated strong agreement with prior knowledge. The adaptive response to BRAF inhibition was dominated by a compensatory induction of SRC-family kinase (SFK) signaling, which we found to be at least partially driven by impaired redox homeostasis and accumulation of reactive oxygen species – providing a fine degree of temporal, mechanistic, and phosphorylation site-specific context to an important axis in tumor cell survival. This induction sensitized cells to co-treatment with an SFK inhibitor, and combination therapy significantly outperformed single-agent BRAF inhibition across a panel of patient-derived melanoma cell lines and in an orthotopic mouse xenograft model, underscoring the high translational potential for measuring the temporal dynamics of signaling and transcription networks under therapeutic challenge.
Project description:A major contributor to poor sensitivity to anti-cancer kinase inhibitor therapy is drug-induced cellular adaptation, whereby remodeling of signaling and gene regulatory networks permits a drug-tolerant phenotype. Here, we resolve the scale and kinetics of critical subcellular events following oncogenic kinase inhibition and preceding cell cycle re-entry, using mass spectrometry-based phosphoproteomics and RNA sequencing to capture molecular snapshots within the first minutes, hours, and days of BRAF kinase inhibitor exposure in a human BRAF-mutant melanoma model of adaptive therapy resistance. By enriching specific phospho-motifs associated with mitogenic kinase activity, we monitored the dynamics of thousands of growth- and survival-related protein phosphorylation events under oncogenic BRAF inhibition and drug removal. We observed early and sustained inhibition of the BRAF-ERK axis, gradual downregulation of canonical cell cycle-dependent signals, and three distinct and reversible phase transitions toward quiescence. Statistical inference of kinetically-defined regulatory modules revealed a concerted response to oncogenic BRAF inhibition and a dominant compensatory induction of SRC family kinase (SFK) signaling, which we found to be at least partially driven by accumulation of reactive oxygen species via impaired redox homeostasis. This induction sensitized cells to co-treatment with an SFK inhibitor across a panel of patient-derived melanoma cell lines and in an orthotopic mouse xenograft model, underscoring the translational potential for measuring the temporal dynamics of signaling and transcriptional networks under therapeutic challenge.
Project description:Neoadjuvant chemotherapy (NAC) remains the cornerstone of treatment for triple negative breast cancer (TNBC) with the goal of complete eradication of disease. However, for patients with residual disease after NAC, recurrence and mortality rates are high and identification of novel therapeutic targets are urgently needed. Here we quantified tyrosine phosphorylation (pTyr) mediated signaling networks in chemotherapy sensitive (CS) and resistant (CR) TNBC patient derived xenografts (PDX) to gain novel therapeutic insights. We identified Src Family Kinases (SFKs) as potential therapeutic targets in CR TNBC PDXs. Treatment with dasatinib, an FDA approved SFK inhibitor, led to inhibition of tumor growth in vivo. Further analysis of post-treatment PDXs revealed multiple mechanisms of actions of the drug confirming the multi-target inhibition of dasatinib. Direct analysis of pTyr in tumor specimens from TNBC patients suggest a low prevalence of SFK driven tumors in the clinic which may explain why clinical trials evaluating dasatinib failed in unselected breast cancer patients. Taken together, these results underscore the importance of pTyr characterization of tumors in identifying new targets as well as stratifying patients based on their activated signaling networks for therapeutic options. Our data also suggest that treatment with an SFK inhibitor may benefit a subset of TNBC patients with CR disease.
Project description:Melanoma cell lines were assessed for differences in gene expression patterns between the lines sensitive and resistant to BRAF and MEK inhibitor drugs. 22 BRAF-mutant melanoma cell lines were assessed for response to BRAF and MEK inhibitors in a 3 day drug treatment dose response assay. Based on the IC50, 18 lines were found to be responsive to BRAF or MEK inhibition and 4 were resistant. Normalised gene expression data generated from experimental replicate affymetrix arrays was assessed to identify differential patterns of inherent gene expression between the cell lines grouped as drug-responsive or drug-resistant. This were used to idenify specific candidate genes and pathways associated with inherent BRAF/MEK inhibitor drug resistance in melanoma cells.
Project description:Drug resistance continues to be a major obstacle to curing cancer. Resistance can evolve from a subpopulation of cancer cells that initially survive drug treatment and then gradually form a pool of slowly growing drug-tolerant cells. Several studies have pinpointed activation of a specific bypass pathway that appears to provide the critical therapeutic target for preventing drug tolerance. Here we take a systems-biology approach using proteomics and genomics to examine the development of drug tolerance to EGFR inhibitors in EGFR-mutant lung adenocarcinoma cells and BRAF inhibitors in BRAF-mutant melanoma cells. We found that there are numerous alternative mitogenic pathways that become activated in both cases, including YAP, STAT3, IGFR1, and phospholipase C (PLC)/protein kinase C (PKC) pathways. Our results suggest that an effective therapeutic strategy to prevent drug tolerance will need to take multiple alternative mitogenic pathways into account rather than focusing on one specific pathway.
Project description:Time course transcription profiling of S. cerevisiae in response to different dynamics of protein kinase A inhibition Time course experiments to analyze dynamics of whole-genome transcription in response to different temporal patterns of protein kinase A inhibition.
Project description:Increased MITF expression contributes to melanoma progression and resistance to BRAF pathway inhibition. We show that, unexpectedly, lack of MITF is associated with more severe resistance to a range of inhibitors. Indeed, the presence of endogenous MITF was essential for robust drug responses. Both in primary and acquired resistance, MITF levels inversely correlated with expression of several activated receptor tyrosine kinases, most commonly AXL. The MITF-low/AXL-high/drug resistance phenotype was seen in roughly half of BRAF mutant and the majority of NRAS mutant melanoma cell lines. The dichotomous behavior of MITF in drug response was corroborated in vemurafenib-resistant biopsies, including MITF high and low clones in a relapsed patient. Drug cocktails containing AXL inhibitor enhanced melanoma cell elimination by BRAF or ERK inhibition. Our results demonstrate that a low MITF/AXL ratio predicts early resistance to multiple targeted drugs, and warrant clinical validation of AXL inhibitors to combat resistance of BRAF and NRAS mutant MITF-low melanomas. Experssion analysis by RNAseq of 14 melanoma cell lines.
Project description:BRAF V600 mutation influences cellular signaling pathways for melanoma development. Here, we show that mutated BRAF plays an essential role in the adaptive stress response following activation of general control non-derepressible 2 (GCN2) kinase. In parallel with GCN2, BRAF ensures ATF4 induction by utilizing mTOR and eIF4B as downstream regulators during nutrient stress and BRAF-targeted, therapeutic stress. Upon pharmacological BRAF inhibition, this signaling pathway exhibits temporal resistance, compared with the MEK-ERK pathway, thereby enabling transient induction of ATF4 under GCN2 activation. Notably, the prevention of GCN2 activation, using a chemical inhibitor that we identified, produces synergistic cell killing with BRAF inhibition. Thus, oncogenic BRAF can collaborate with the GCN2–ATF4 pathway, promoting stress adaptation for cell survival.
Project description:BRAF V600 mutation influences cellular signaling pathways for melanoma development. Here, we show that mutated BRAF plays an essential role in the adaptive stress response following activation of general control non-derepressible 2 (GCN2) kinase. In parallel with GCN2, BRAF ensures ATF4 induction by utilizing mTOR and eIF4B as downstream regulators during nutrient stress and BRAF-targeted, therapeutic stress. Upon pharmacological BRAF inhibition, this signaling pathway exhibits temporal resistance, compared with the MEK-ERK pathway, thereby enabling transient induction of ATF4 under GCN2 activation. Notably, the prevention of GCN2 activation, using a chemical inhibitor that we identified, produces synergistic cell killing with BRAF inhibition. Thus, oncogenic BRAF can collaborate with the GCN2–ATF4 pathway, promoting stress adaptation for cell survival.
Project description:Increased MITF expression contributes to melanoma progression and resistance to BRAF pathway inhibition. We show that, unexpectedly, lack of MITF is associated with more severe resistance to a range of inhibitors. Indeed, the presence of endogenous MITF was essential for robust drug responses. Both in primary and acquired resistance, MITF levels inversely correlated with expression of several activated receptor tyrosine kinases, most commonly AXL. The MITF-low/AXL-high/drug resistance phenotype was seen in roughly half of BRAF mutant and the majority of NRAS mutant melanoma cell lines. The dichotomous behavior of MITF in drug response was corroborated in vemurafenib-resistant biopsies, including MITF high and low clones in a relapsed patient. Drug cocktails containing AXL inhibitor enhanced melanoma cell elimination by BRAF or ERK inhibition. Our results demonstrate that a low MITF/AXL ratio predicts early resistance to multiple targeted drugs, and warrant clinical validation of AXL inhibitors to combat resistance of BRAF and NRAS mutant MITF-low melanomas.
Project description:Recent data demonstrate that extracellular signals are transmitted through a network of proteins rather than hierarchical signaling pathways. This network model suggests why inhibition of a single component of a canonical pathway, even when targeting a mutationally activated driver of cancer, has insufficiently dramatic effects on the treatment of cancer. The biological outcome of signals propagated through a network is inherently more robust and resistant to inhibition of a single network component due to compensatory and redundant signaling events. In this study, we performed a functional chemical genetic screen analogous to synthetic lethal screening in yeast genetics to identify novel interactions between signaling inhibitors that would not be predicted based on our current understanding of signaling networks. We screened over 300 drug combinations in nine melanoma cell lines and have identified pairs of compounds that show synergistic cytotoxicity. Among the most robust and surprising results was synergy between sorafenib, a multi-kinase inhibitor with activity against Raf, and diclofenac, a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID). This synergy did not correlate with the known RAS and BRAF mutational status of the melanoma cell lines. The NSAIDs celecoxib and ibuprofen could qualitatively substitute for diclofenac. Similarly, the MEK inhibitor PD325901 and the Raf inhibitor RAF265 could qualitatively substitute for sorafenib. These drug substitution experiments suggest that inhibition of cyclo-oxygenase and MAP kinase signaling are components of the observed synergistic cytotoxicity. Genome-wide expression profiling demonstrates synergy-specific down-regulation of survival-related genes. This study provides proof of principle that synthetic lethal screening can uncover novel functional drug combinations and suggests that the underlying signaling networks that control responses to targeted agents can vary substantially depending on unexplored components of the cell genotype. RNA from VMM39, DM331, and SLM2 cells with/without mutations in Ras and/or Braf, treated with Sorafenib and/or Diclofenac.