Binary cell fate decision as high-dimensional critical state transition

ABSTRACT: During commitment of a multipotent stem or progenitor cell to a particular lineage, a large number of genes alter their expression in a coordinated manner orchestrated by the gene regulatory network (GRN). The constraints imposed by the GRN govern how cells move in the high-dimensional gene expression state space and can be understood as a dynamical system in which phenotypic cell states (cell types) are attractors that stabilize the cell-type characteristic gene expression pattern against molecular noise. Despite insights from various theoretical models, it remains elusive how multipotent cells, when committing to a specific lineage, exit their attractor and enter a new distinct attractor. Here we show, using single-cell resolution monitoring of transcript patterns by qPCR that commitment of multipotent blood progenitor cells to either the erythroid or the myeloid lineage is preceded by a destabilization of the progenitors’ attractor state and a slowing-down of relaxation of cells from outlier states, indicating a critical state transition (“tipping point”). The high-dimensionality of the system (many genes) and availability of individual trajectories of a large ensemble of systems (many cells) affords a novel signature for critical transition which can be predicted from theory: Decrease of correlation between cells and concomitant increase of correlation between genes as the cell population approaches the tipping point. Consistent with a destabilizing bifurcation that simultaneously opens access to the erythroid and myeloid attractors, differentiation signal for either lineage caused some cells to commit to the “wrong” fate; moreover providing conflicting signals resulted in a delayed decision at the bifurcation point that however was ultimately resolved by commitment to one fate. These results suggest that the theoretical framework of “early-warning signs” and critical transitions can be applied to ensembles of high-dimensional systems, offering a formal tool for analyzing single-cell omics data beyond current descriptive computational pattern recognition.

ORGANISM(S): Mus musculus

PROVIDER: GSE70405 | GEO | 2016/09/01

SECONDARY ACCESSION(S): PRJNA288570

REPOSITORIES: GEO