Dataset Information

Gene frequency distributions reject a neutral model of genome evolution.

ABSTRACT: Evolution of prokaryotes involves extensive loss and gain of genes, which lead to substantial differences in the gene repertoires even among closely related organisms. Through a wide range of phylogenetic depths, gene frequency distributions in prokaryotic pangenomes bear a characteristic, asymmetrical U-shape, with a core of (nearly) universal genes, a "shell" of moderately common genes, and a "cloud" of rare genes. We employ mathematical modeling to investigate evolutionary processes that might underlie this universal pattern. Gene frequency distributions for almost 400 groups of 10 bacterial or archaeal species each over a broad range of evolutionary distances were fit to steady-state, infinite allele models based on the distribution of gene replacement rates and the phylogenetic tree relating the species in each group. The fits of the theoretical frequency distributions to the empirical ones yield model parameters and estimates of the goodness of fit. Using the Akaike Information Criterion, we show that the neutral model of genome evolution, with the same replacement rate for all genes, can be confidently rejected. Of the three tested models with purifying selection, the one in which the distribution of replacement rates is derived from a stochastic population model with additive per-gene fitness yields the best fits to the data. The selection strength estimated from the fits declines with evolutionary divergence while staying well outside the neutral regime. These findings indicate that, unlike some other universal distributions of genomic variables, for example, the distribution of paralogous gene family membership, the gene frequency distribution is substantially affected by selection.

SUBMITTER: Lobkovsky AE

PROVIDER: S-EPMC3595032 | biostudies-literature | 2013

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Gene frequency distributions reject a neutral model of genome evolution.

Lobkovsky Alexander E AE Wolf Yuri I YI Koonin Eugene V EV

Genome biology and evolution 20130101 1

Evolution of prokaryotes involves extensive loss and gain of genes, which lead to substantial differences in the gene repertoires even among closely related organisms. Through a wide range of phylogenetic depths, gene frequency distributions in prokaryotic pangenomes bear a characteristic, asymmetrical U-shape, with a core of (nearly) universal genes, a "shell" of moderately common genes, and a "cloud" of rare genes. We employ mathematical modeling to investigate evolutionary processes that migh ...[more]

PMID: 23315380

Similar Datasets

Project description:BackgroundThe gene composition of bacteria of the same species can differ significantly between isolates. Variability in gene composition can be summarized in terms of gene frequency distributions, in which individual genes are ranked according to the frequency of genomes in which they appear. Empirical gene frequency distributions possess a U-shape, such that there are many rare genes, some genes of intermediate occurrence, and many common genes. It would seem that U-shaped gene frequency distributions can be used to infer the essentiality and/or importance of a gene to a species. Here, we ask: can U-shaped gene frequency distributions, instead, arise generically via neutral processes of genome evolution?ResultsWe introduce a neutral model of genome evolution which combines birth-death processes at the organismal level with gene uptake and loss at the genomic level. This model predicts that gene frequency distributions possess a characteristic U-shape even in the absence of selective forces driving genome and population structure. We compare the model predictions to empirical gene frequency distributions from 6 multiply sequenced species of bacterial pathogens. We fit the model with constant population size to data, matching U-shape distributions albeit without matching all quantitative features of the distribution. We find stronger model fits in the case where we consider exponentially growing populations. We also show that two alternative models which contain a "rigid" and "flexible" core component of genomes provide strong fits to gene frequency distributions.ConclusionsThe analysis of neutral models of genome evolution suggests that U-shaped gene frequency distributions provide less information than previously suggested regarding gene essentiality. We discuss the need for additional theory and genomic level information to disentangle the roles of evolutionary mechanisms operating within and amongst individuals in driving the dynamics of gene distributions.

Project description:Key string algorithm (KSA) could be viewed as robust computational generalization of restriction enzyme method. KSA enables robust and effective identification and structural analyzes of any given genomic sequences, like in the case of NCBI assembly for human genome. We have developed a method, using total frequency distribution of all r-bp key strings in dependence on the fragment length l, to determine the exact size of all repeats within the given genomic sequence, both of monomeric and HOR type. Subsequently, for particular fragment lengths equal to each of these repeat sizes we compute the partial frequency distribution of r-bp key strings; the key string with highest frequency is a dominant key string, optimal for segmentation of a given genomic sequence into repeat units. We illustrate how a wide class of 3-bp key strings leads to a key-string-dependent periodic cell which enables a simple identification and consensus length determinations of HORs, or any other highly convergent repeat of monomeric or HOR type, both tandem or dispersed. We illustrated KSA application for HORs in human genome and determined consensus HORs in the Build 35.1 assembly. In the next step we compute suprachromosomal family classification and CENP-B box / pJalpha distributions for HORs. In the case of less convergent repeats, like for example monomeric alpha satellite (20-40% divergence), we searched for optimal compact key string using frequency method and developed a concept of composite key string (GAAAC--CTTTG) or flexible relaxation (28 bp key string) which provides both monomeric alpha satellites as well as alpha monomer segmentation of internal HOR structure. This method is convenient also for study of R-strand (direct) / S-strand (reverse complement) alpha monomer alternations. Using KSA we identified 16 alternating regions of R-strand and S-strand monomers in one contig in choromosome 7. Use of CENP-B box and/or pJalpha motif as key string is suitable both for identification of HORs and monomeric pattern as well as for studies of CENP-B box / pJalpha distribution. As an example of application of KSA to sequences outside of HOR regions we present our finding of a tandem with highly convergent 3434-bp Long monomer in chromosome 5 (divergence less then 0.3%).

Dataset Information

Gene frequency distributions reject a neutral model of genome evolution.

Publications

Gene frequency distributions reject a neutral model of genome evolution.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets