Dataset Information

Are current atomistic force fields accurate enough to study proteins in crowded environments?

ABSTRACT: The high concentration of macromolecules in the crowded cellular interior influences different thermodynamic and kinetic properties of proteins, including their structural stabilities, intermolecular binding affinities and enzymatic rates. Moreover, various structural biology methods, such as NMR or different spectroscopies, typically involve samples with relatively high protein concentration. Due to large sampling requirements, however, the accuracy of classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations in capturing protein behavior at high concentration still remains largely untested. Here, we use explicit-solvent MD simulations and a total of 6.4 µs of simulated time to study wild-type (folded) and oxidatively damaged (unfolded) forms of villin headpiece at 6 mM and 9.2 mM protein concentration. We first perform an exhaustive set of simulations with multiple protein molecules in the simulation box using GROMOS 45a3 and 54a7 force fields together with different types of electrostatics treatment and solution ionic strengths. Surprisingly, the two villin headpiece variants exhibit similar aggregation behavior, despite the fact that their estimated aggregation propensities markedly differ. Importantly, regardless of the simulation protocol applied, wild-type villin headpiece consistently aggregates even under conditions at which it is experimentally known to be soluble. We demonstrate that aggregation is accompanied by a large decrease in the total potential energy, with not only hydrophobic, but also polar residues and backbone contributing substantially. The same effect is directly observed for two other major atomistic force fields (AMBER99SB-ILDN and CHARMM22-CMAP) as well as indirectly shown for additional two (AMBER94, OPLS-AAL), and is possibly due to a general overestimation of the potential energy of protein-protein interactions at the expense of water-water and water-protein interactions. Overall, our results suggest that current MD force fields may distort the picture of protein behavior in biologically relevant crowded environments.

SUBMITTER: Petrov D

PROVIDER: S-EPMC4031056 | biostudies-literature | 2014 May

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Are current atomistic force fields accurate enough to study proteins in crowded environments?

Petrov Drazen D Zagrovic Bojan B

PLoS computational biology 20140522 5

The high concentration of macromolecules in the crowded cellular interior influences different thermodynamic and kinetic properties of proteins, including their structural stabilities, intermolecular binding affinities and enzymatic rates. Moreover, various structural biology methods, such as NMR or different spectroscopies, typically involve samples with relatively high protein concentration. Due to large sampling requirements, however, the accuracy of classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulati ...[more]

PMID: 24854339

Similar Datasets

Project description:Long dynamics simulations were carried out on the B1 immunoglobulin-binding domain of streptococcal protein G (ProtG) and bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI) using atomistic descriptions of the proteins and a continuum representation of solvent effects. To mimic frictional and random collision effects, Langevin dynamics (LD) were used. The main goal of the calculations was to explore the stability of tens-of-nanosecond trajectories as generated by this molecular mechanics approximation and to analyze in detail structural and dynamical properties. Conformational fluctuations, order parameters, cross correlation matrices, residue solvent accessibilities, pKa values of titratable groups, and hydrogen-bonding (HB) patterns were calculated from all of the trajectories and compared with available experimental data. The simulations comprised over 40 ns per trajectory for ProtG and over 30 ns per trajectory for BPTI. For comparison, explicit water molecular dynamics simulations (EW/MD) of 3 ns and 4 ns, respectively, were also carried out. Two continuum simulations were performed on each protein using the CHARMM program, one with the all-atom PAR22 representation of the protein force field (here referred to as PAR22/LD simulations) and the other with the modifications introduced by the recently developed CMAP potential (CMAP/LD simulations). The explicit solvent simulations were performed with PAR22 only. Solvent effects are described by a continuum model based on screened Coulomb potentials (SCP) reported earlier, i.e., the SCP-based implicit solvent model (SCP-ISM). For ProtG, both the PAR22/LD and the CMAP/LD 40-ns trajectories were stable, yielding C(alpha) root mean square deviations (RMSD) of about 1.0 and 0.8 A respectively along the entire simulation time, compared to 0.8 A for the EW/MD simulation. For BPTI, only the CMAP/LD trajectory was stable for the entire 30-ns simulation, with a C(alpha) RMSD of approximately 1.4 A, while the PAR22/LD trajectory became unstable early in the simulation, reaching a C(alpha) RMSD of about 2.7 A and remaining at this value until the end of the simulation; the C(alpha) RMSD of the EW/MD simulation was about 1.5 A. The source of the instabilities of the BPTI trajectories in the PAR22/LD simulations was explored by an analysis of the backbone torsion angles. To further validate the findings from this analysis of BPTI, a 35-ns SCP-ISM simulation of Ubiquitin (Ubq) was carried out. For this protein, the CMAP/LD simulation was stable for the entire simulation time (C(alpha) RMSD of approximately 1.0 A), while the PAR22/LD trajectory showed a trend similar to that in BPTI, reaching a C(alpha) RMSD of approximately 1.5 A at 7 ns. All the calculated properties were found to be in agreement with the corresponding experimental values, although local deviations were also observed. HB patterns were also well reproduced by all the continuum solvent simulations with the exception of solvent-exposed side chain-side chain (sc-sc) HB in ProtG, where several of the HB interactions observed in the crystal structure and in the EW/MD simulation were lost. The overall analysis reported in this work suggests that the combination of an atomistic representation of a protein with a CMAP/CHARMM force field and a continuum representation of solvent effects such as the SCP-ISM provides a good description of structural and dynamic properties obtained from long computer simulations. Although the SCP-ISM simulations (CMAP/LD) reported here were shown to be stable and the properties well reproduced, further refinement is needed to attain a level of accuracy suitable for more challenging biological applications, particularly the study of protein-protein interactions.

Dataset Information

Are current atomistic force fields accurate enough to study proteins in crowded environments?

Publications

Are current atomistic force fields accurate enough to study proteins in crowded environments?

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets