Randomized trial comparing the 22-gauge aspiration and 22-gauge biopsy needles for EUS-guided sampling of solid pancreatic mass lesions.

ABSTRACT:

Background

To overcome limitations of cytology, biopsy needles have been developed to procure histologic samples during EUS.

Objective

To compare 22-gauge (G) FNA and 22G biopsy needles (FNB) for EUS-guided sampling of solid pancreatic masses.

Design

Randomized trial.

Setting

Tertiary-care medical center.

Patients

This study involved 56 patients with solid pancreatic masses.

Intervention

Sampling of pancreatic masses by using 22G FNA or 22G FNB devices.

Main outcome measurements

Compare the median number of passes required to establish the diagnosis, diagnostic sufficiency, technical performance, complication rates, procurement of the histologic core, and quality of the histologic specimen.

Results

A total of 28 patients were randomized to the FNA group and 28 to the FNB group. There was no significant difference in median number of passes required to establish the diagnosis (1 [interquartile range 1-2.5] vs 1 [interquartile range 1-1]; P = .21), rates of diagnostic sufficiency (100% vs 89.3%; P = .24), technical failure (0 vs 3.6%; P = 1.0), or complications (3.6% for both) between FNA and FNB needles, respectively. Patients in whom diagnosis was established in passes 1, 2, and 3 were 64.3% versus 67.9%, 10.7% versus 17.9%, and 25% versus 3.6%, respectively, for FNA and FNB cohorts. There was no significant difference in procurement of the histologic core (100% vs 83.3%; P = .26) or the presence of diagnostic histologic specimens (66.7% vs 80%; P = .66) between FNA and FNB cohorts, respectively.

Limitations

Only pancreatic masses were evaluated.

Conclusion

Diagnostic sufficiency, technical performance, and safety profiles of FNA and FNB needles are comparable. There was no significant difference in yield or quality of the histologic core between the 2 needle types.

SUBMITTER: Bang JY 

PROVIDER: S-EPMC4148209 | biostudies-literature | 2012 Aug

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature