Dataset Information

Subject-Motion Correction in HARDI Acquisitions: Choices and Consequences.

ABSTRACT: Diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) is known to be prone to artifacts related to motion originating from subject movement, cardiac pulsation, and breathing, but also to mechanical issues such as table vibrations. Given the necessity for rigorous quality control and motion correction, users are often left to use simple heuristics to select correction schemes, which involves simple qualitative viewing of the set of DWI data, or the selection of transformation parameter thresholds for detection of motion outliers. The scientific community offers strong theoretical and experimental work on noise reduction and orientation distribution function (ODF) reconstruction techniques for HARDI data, where post-acquisition motion correction is widely performed, e.g., using the open-source DTIprep software (1), FSL (the FMRIB Software Library) (2), or TORTOISE (3). Nonetheless, effects and consequences of the selection of motion correction schemes on the final analysis, and the eventual risk of introducing confounding factors when comparing populations, are much less known and far beyond simple intuitive guessing. Hence, standard users lack clear guidelines and recommendations in practical settings. This paper reports a comprehensive evaluation framework to systematically assess the outcome of different motion correction choices commonly used by the scientific community on different DWI-derived measures. We make use of human brain HARDI data from a well-controlled motion experiment to simulate various degrees of motion corruption and noise contamination. Choices for correction include exclusion/scrubbing or registration of motion corrupted directions with different choices of interpolation, as well as the option of interpolation of all directions. The comparative evaluation is based on a study of the impact of motion correction using four metrics that quantify (1) similarity of fiber orientation distribution functions (fODFs), (2) deviation of local fiber orientations, (3) global brain connectivity via graph diffusion distance (GDD), and (4) the reproducibility of prominent and anatomically defined fiber tracts. Effects of various motion correction choices are systematically explored and illustrated, leading to a general conclusion of discouraging users from setting ad hoc thresholds on the estimated motion parameters beyond which volumes are claimed to be corrupted.

SUBMITTER: Elhabian S

PROVIDER: S-EPMC4260507 | biostudies-literature | 2014

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Subject-Motion Correction in HARDI Acquisitions: Choices and Consequences.

Elhabian Shireen S Gur Yaniv Y Vachet Clement C Piven Joseph J Styner Martin M Leppert Ilana R IR Pike G Bruce GB Gerig Guido G

Frontiers in neurology 20141209

Diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) is known to be prone to artifacts related to motion originating from subject movement, cardiac pulsation, and breathing, but also to mechanical issues such as table vibrations. Given the necessity for rigorous quality control and motion correction, users are often left to use simple heuristics to select correction schemes, which involves simple qualitative viewing of the set of DWI data, or the selection of transformation parameter thresholds for detection of mot ...[more]

PMID: 25538672

Similar Datasets

Project description:Worldwide, crop production is intrinsically intertwined with biological, environmental and economic systems, all of which involve complex, inter-related and spatially-sensitive phenomena. Thus knowing the location of agriculture matters much for a host of reasons. There are several widely cited attempts to model the spatial pattern of crop production worldwide, not least by pixilating crop production statistics originally reported on an areal (administrative boundary) basis. However, these modeled measures have had little scrutiny regarding the robustness of their results to alternative data and modeling choices. Our research casts a critical eye over the nature and empirical plausibility of these types of datasets. To do so, we determine the sensitivity of the 2005 variant of the spatial production allocation model data series (SPAM2005) to eight methodological-cum-data choices in nine agriculturally-large and developmentally-variable countries: Brazil, China, Ethiopia, France, India, Indonesia, Nigeria, Turkey and the United States. We compare the original published estimates with those obtained from a series of robustness tests using various aggregations of the pixelized spatial production indicators (specifically, commodity-specific harvested area, production quantity and yield). Spatial similarity is empirically assessed using a pixel-level spatial similarity index (SSI). We find that the SPAM2005 estimates are most dependent on the degree of disaggregation of the underlying national and subnational production statistics. The results are also somewhat sensitive to the use of a simple spatial allocation method based solely on cropland proportions versus a cross-entropy allocation method, as well as the set of crops or crop aggregates being modeled, and are least sensitive to the inclusion of crude economic elements. Finally, we assess the spatial concordance between the SPAM2005 estimates of the area harvested of major crops in the United States and pixelated measures derived from remote-sensed data.

Project description:BackgroundThere are many sources of variation in dual labelled microarray experiments, including data acquisition and image processing. The final interpretation of experiments strongly relies on the accuracy of the measurement of the signal intensity. For low intensity spots in particular, accurately estimating gene expression variations remains a challenge as signal measurement is, in this case, highly subject to fluctuations.ResultsTo evaluate the fluctuations in the fluorescence intensities of spots, we used series of successive scans, at the same settings, of whole genome arrays. We measured the decrease in fluorescence and we evaluated the influence of different parameters (PMT gain, resolution and chemistry of the slide) on the signal variability, at the level of the array as a whole and by intensity interval. Moreover, we assessed the effect of averaging scans on the fluctuations. We found that the extent of photo-bleaching was low and we established that 1) the fluorescence fluctuation is linked to the resolution e.g. it depends on the number of pixels in the spot 2) the fluorescence fluctuation increases as the scanner voltage increases and, moreover, is higher for the red as opposed to the green fluorescence which can introduce bias in the analysis 3) the signal variability is linked to the intensity level, it is higher for low intensities 4) the heterogeneity of the spots and the variability of the signal and the intensity ratios decrease when two or three scans are averaged.ConclusionProtocols consisting of two scans, one at low and one at high PMT gains, or multiple scans (ten scans) can introduce bias or be difficult to implement. We found that averaging two, or at most three, acquisitions of microarrays scanned at moderate photomultiplier settings (PMT gain) is sufficient to significantly improve the accuracy (quality) of the data and particularly those for spots having low intensities and we propose this as a general approach. For averaging and precise image alignment at sub-pixel levels we have made a program freely available on our web-site http://bioinfome.cgm.cnrs-gif.fr to facilitate implementation of this approach.

Project description:BackgroundExternal defibrillators are used for arrhythmia cardioversion and for defibrillating during cardiac arrest. During defibrillation, short-duration biphasic pulses cause intense motion due to rapid chest-wall muscle contraction. A reduced motion external defibrillator (RMD) was constructed by integrating a commercial defibrillator with a Tetanizing-waveform generator. A long-duration, low-amplitude, tetanizing waveform slowly stimulated the chest musculature before the biphasic pulse, reducing muscle contraction during the shock.ObjectiveThe purpose of this study was to evaluate RMD defibrillation in swine for subject motion during defibrillation pulses and for defibrillation effectiveness. RMD defibrillation can reduce the duration of arrhythmia ablation therapy or simplify cardioversion procedures.MethodsThe tetanizing unit delivered a triangular 1-kHz pulse of 0.25- to 2.0-second duration and 10- to 100-V peak amplitude, subsequently triggering the conventional defibrillator to output standard 1- to 200-J energy biphasic pulses at the next R wave. Forward limb motion was evaluated by measuring peak acceleration and limb work during RMD (tetanizing + biphasic) or biphasic pulse-only waveforms at 10-3-second sampling rate. Seven swine were arrested electrically and subsequently defibrillated. Biphasic pulse-only and RMD defibrillations were repeated 25-35 times per swine, varying tetanizing parameters and biphasic pulse energy. Defibrillation thresholds (DFTs) were established by measuring the minimum energy required to restore sinus rhythm with biphasic pulse-only or RMD defibrillations.ResultsTwo forward-limb acceleration peaks occurred during both the tetanizing waveform and biphasic pulse, indicating rapid and slower nociceptic (pain sensation) nerve fiber activation. Optimal RMD tetanizing parameters (25-35 V, 0.25- to 0.75-second duration), relative to biphasic pulse-only defibrillations, resulted in 74% ± 10% smaller peak accelerations and 85% ± 10% reduced limb work. DFT energies were identical when comparing RMD to biphasic pulse-only defibrillations.ConclusionRelative to conventional defibrillations, RMD defibrillations maintain rhythm restoration efficiency with drastically reduced subject motion.

Project description:Most cases of alternative reproductive tactics (ARTs) are thought to represent conditional strategies, whereby high-status males express highly competitive phenotypes, whereas males below a certain status threshold resort to sneaky tactics. The underlying evolutionarily stable strategy (ESS) model assumes that males of high competitive ability achieve higher fitness when expressing the territorial phenotype, whereas the less competitive males are more fit as sneakers, caused by fitness functions for the ARTs having different slopes and intersecting at a threshold value of competitive ability. The model, however, is notoriously difficult to test as it requires access to low-status territorials and high-status sneakers, that rarely occur in nature. Here, we test the conditional ESS in the androdimorphic acarid mite Sancassania berlesei, where large males tend to develop into an armoured, aggressive 'fighter' morph, while small males become unarmoured, non-aggressive 'scramblers'. In addition to body size, male morph is affected by pheromones produced by big populations, with fighters being suppressed in dense colonies. By manipulating pheromone concentration, we obtained high-status scramblers and low-status fighters. We also estimated status- and size-dependent fitness functions for male morphs across a range of population sizes. Fighters had the highest fitness in small populations and their fitness declined with increasing density, whereas the reverse was true for scramblers, providing support for condition-dependent ESS with respect to demography. However, whereas male fitness increased with body size, the fitness functions did not differ significantly between morphs. Thus, although we found evidence for the intersection of morph fitness functions with respect to demography, we did not find such an intersection in relation to male body size. Our results highlight how demography can exert selection pressures shaping the evolution of the conditional strategy in species with ARTs.

Dataset Information

Subject-Motion Correction in HARDI Acquisitions: Choices and Consequences.

Publications

Subject-Motion Correction in HARDI Acquisitions: Choices and Consequences.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets