Inter-observer variability of organ contouring for preclinical studies with cone beam Computed Tomography imaging
Ontology highlight
ABSTRACT: Background and purpose
In preclinical radiation studies, there is great interest in quantifying the radiation response of healthy tissues. Manual contouring has significant impact on the treatment-planning because of variation introduced by human interpretation. This results in inconsistencies when assessing normal tissue volumes. Evaluation of these discrepancies can provide a better understanding on the limitations of the current preclinical radiation workflow. In the present work, interobserver variability (IOV) in manual contouring of rodent normal tissues on cone-beam Computed Tomography, in head and thorax regions was evaluated. Materials and methods
Two animal technicians performed manually (assisted) contouring of normal tissues located within the thorax and head regions of rodents, 20 cases per body site. Mean surface distance (MSD), displacement of center of mass (ΔCoM), DICE similarity coefficient (DSC) and the 95th percentile Hausdorff distance (HD95) were calculated between the contours of the two observers to evaluate the IOV. Results
For the thorax organs, right lung had the lowest IOV (ΔCoM: 0.08 ± 0.04 mm, DSC: 0.96 ± 0.01, MSD:0.07 ± 0.01 mm, HD95:0.20 ± 0.03 mm) while spinal cord, the highest IOV (ΔCoM:0.5 ± 0.3 mm, DSC:0.81 ± 0.05, MSD:0.14 ± 0.03 mm, HD95:0.8 ± 0.2 mm). Regarding head organs, right eye demonstrated the lowest IOV (ΔCoM:0.12 ± 0.08 mm, DSC: 0.93 ± 0.02, MSD: 0.15 ± 0.04 mm, HD95: 0.29 ± 0.07 mm) while complete brain, the highest IOV (ΔCoM: 0.2 ± 0.1 mm, DSC: 0.94 ± 0.02, MSD: 0.3 ± 0.1 mm, HD95: 0.5 ± 0.1 mm). Conclusions
Our findings reveal small IOV, within the sub-mm range, for thorax and head normal tissues in rodents. The set of contours can serve as a basis for developing an automated delineation method for e.g., treatment planning.
SUBMITTER: Lappas G
PROVIDER: S-EPMC8790504 | biostudies-literature |
REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature
Similar Datasets
Project description:Background and purposeRadiomics analysis extracts quantitative data (features) from medical images. These features could potentially reflect biological characteristics and act as imaging biomarkers within precision medicine. However, there is a lack of cross-comparison and validation of radiomics outputs which is paramount for clinical implementation. In this study, we compared radiomics outputs across two computed tomography (CT)-based preclinical scanners.Materials and methodsCone beam CT (CBCT) and µCT scans were acquired using different preclinical CT imaging platforms. The reproducibility of radiomics features on each scanner was assessed using a phantom across imaging energies (40 & 60 kVp) and segmentation volumes (44-238 mm3). Retrospective mouse scans were used to compare feature reliability across varying tissue densities (lung, heart, bone), scanners and after voxel size harmonisation. Reliable features had an intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) > 0.8.ResultsFirst order and GLCM features were the most reliable on both scanners across different volumes. There was an inverse relationship between tissue density and feature reliability, with the highest number of features in lung (CBCT=580, µCT=734) and lowest in bone (CBCT=110, µCT=560). Comparable features for lung and heart tissues increased when voxel sizes were harmonised. We have identified tissue-specific preclinical radiomics signatures in mice for the lung (133), heart (35), and bone (15).ConclusionsPreclinical CBCT and µCT scans can be used for radiomics analysis to support the development of meaningful radiomics signatures. This study demonstrates the importance of standardisation and emphasises the need for multi-centre studies.
| S-EPMC11328005 | biostudies-literature
Project description:ObjectiveTo determine inter-observer and inter-examination variability of manual attenuation measurements of the vertebrae in low-dose unenhanced chest computed tomography (CT).MethodsThree hundred and sixty-seven lung cancer screening trial participants who underwent baseline and repeat unenhanced low-dose CT after 3 months because of an indeterminate lung nodule were included. The CT attenuation value of the first lumbar vertebrae (L1) was measured in all CTs by one observer to obtain inter-examination reliability. Six observers performed measurements in 100 randomly selected CTs to determine agreement with limits of agreement and Bland-Altman plots and reliability with intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). Reclassification analyses were performed using a threshold of 110 HU to define osteoporosis.ResultsInter-examination reliability was excellent with an ICC of 0.92 (p < 0.001). Inter-examination limits of agreement ranged from -26 to 28 HU with a mean difference of 1 ± 14 HU. Inter-observer reliability ICCs ranged from 0.70 to 0.91. Inter-examination variability led to 11.2 % reclassification of participants and inter-observer variability led to 22.1 % reclassification.ConclusionsVertebral attenuation values can be manually quantified with good to excellent inter-examination and inter-observer reliability on unenhanced low-dose chest CT. This information is valuable for early detection of osteoporosis on low-dose chest CT.Key points• Vertebral attenuation values can be manually quantified on low-dose unenhanced CT reliably. • Vertebral attenuation measurements may be helpful in detecting subclinical low bone density. • This could become of importance in the detection of osteoporosis.
| S-EPMC4972882 | biostudies-literature
Project description:PurposeEvaluation of skin organ doses in six different cone-beam computed tomography scanners (CBCT) dedicated to dentomaxillofacial imaging. Our hypothesis is that the dose varies between different devices, protocols and skin areas.Materials and methodsAn anthropomorphic adult head and neck phantom was used to which a dosimeter (Waterproof Farmer® Chamber, PTW, Freiburg, Germany) was attached to anatomic landmarks of both parotid glands, both ocular lenses, the thyroid gland and the neurocranium. CBCT examinations were performed on six different CBCT devices dedicated to dentomaxillofacial imaging with standard settings and, if available, also in high dose settings. Measurements were repeated five times each.ResultsThe measured mean skin doses ranged from 0.48 to 2.21 mGy. The comparison of the region based dose evaluation showed a high correlation between the single measurements. Furthermore, the distribution of doses between regions was similar in all devices, except that four devices showed side differences for the dose of the parotid region and one device showed side differences for the lens region. The directly exposed regions, such as the parotid glands, showed significant higher values than the more distant regions like the neurocranium. When comparing examination protocols, a significant difference between the standard dose and the high dose acquisitions could be detected. But also a significant dose difference between the different CBCTs could be shown. 3D Accuitomo 170 (Morita, Osaka, Japan) showed the highest absorbed mean dose value for standard settings with 2.21 mGy, especially at the directly exposed regions and their adjacent organs. The lowest mean value for standard settings was achieved with VGi evo (NewTom, Verona, Italy) with 0.48 mGy.ConclusionRepeated measurements of skin organ doses in six different CBCT scanners using a surface dosimeter showed side differences in distribution of dose in five devices for the parotid and lens region. Additionally, significant dose differences between the devices could be detected. Further studies should be performed to confirm these results.
| S-EPMC8274873 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Background and purposeThe delineation of the gross tumor volume (GTV) is a critical step for radiation therapy treatment planning. The delineation procedure is typically performed manually which exposes two major issues: cost and reproducibility. Delineation is a time-consuming process that is subject to inter- and intra-observer variability. While methods have been proposed to predict GTV contours, typical approaches ignore variability and therefore fail to utilize the valuable confidence information offered by multiple contours.Materials and methodsIn this work we propose an automatic GTV contouring method for soft-tissue sarcomas from X-ray computed tomography (CT) images, using deep learning by integrating inter- and intra-observer variability in the learned model. Sixty-eight patients with soft tissue and bone sarcomas were considered in this evaluation, all underwent pre-operative CT imaging used to perform GTV delineation. Four radiation oncologists and radiologists performed three contouring trials each for all patients. We quantify variability by defining confidence levels based on the frequency of inclusion of a given voxel into the GTV and use a deep convolutional neural network to learn GTV confidence maps.ResultsResults were compared to confidence maps from the four readers as well as ground-truth consensus contours established jointly by all readers. The resulting continuous Dice score between predicted and true confidence maps was 87% and the Hausdorff distance was 14 mm.ConclusionResults demonstrate the ability of the proposed method to predict accurate contours while utilizing variability and as such it can be used to improve clinical workflow.
| S-EPMC8934266 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Background and purposeOrgan motion is a challenge during high-precision external beam radiotherapy in cervical cancer, and improved strategies for treatment adaptation and monitoring of target dose coverage are needed. This study evaluates a cone beam computed tomography (CBCT)-based approach.Materials and methodsIn twenty-three patients, individualized internal target volumes (ITVs) were generated from pre-treatment MRI and CT scans with full and empty bladders. The target volumes encompassed high-risk clinical target volume (CTV-T HR) (gross tumor volume + remaining cervix) and low risk (LR) CTV-T (CTV-T HR + uterus + parametriae + upper vagina). Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy (VMAT) was used to deliver a dose of 45 Gy in 25 fractions. CBCTs were used for setup and for radiation therapists (RTTs) to evaluate the target coverage (inside/outside the planning target volume). CBCTs were reviewed offline. Estimates of the dose delivered with minimum (point) doses across all fractions to CTV-T HR (aim 42.75 Gy) and CTV-T LR (aim 40 Gy) were assessed. In patients with insufficient dose coverage, re-plans were generated based on previous imaging.ResultsMedian (range) of the ITV-margins (mean of anterior-posterior margins) related to uterus and cervix was 1.2 (0.5-2.2 and 1.0-2.1) cm. RTTs were able to assess the target coverage in 90% of all CBCTs (505/563). With re-planning, one patient had considerable benefit (12.7 Gy increase of minimum dose) to CTV-T LR_vagina, four patients had improved dose to the CTV-T LR_uterus (1.2-1.8 Gy), and 3 patients did not benefit from re-planning.ConclusionsDaily CBCT-based monitoring of target coverage by the RTTs has proven safe with limited workload. It allows for reduction in the treated volumes without compromising the target dose coverage.
| S-EPMC7807672 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Purpose To establish a practical contouring strategy with reference atlases for the abdominopelvic bowel bag on treatment planning computed tomography (TPCT) and cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) images. Methods and Materials A scoping literature review was done to evaluate the existing definitions and contouring guidelines for bowel bag and small bowel planning-at-risk volume–like structures. A comprehensive definition was proposed for the abdominopelvic bowel bag that expanded the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group Pelvic Normal Tissue Consensus definition. Seven patients with TPCT and first-treatment-day CBCT images were selected from an institutional database to represent a range of normal anatomy and CBCT image quality. The TPCT and CBCT images were contoured using the proposed definition. During contouring, the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group definition's list of inclusion and exclusion structures was expanded. For areas with limited visibility of the bowel bag on either TPCT or CBCT, a set of operational definitions was developed based on consistently visible reference structures. Results A literature review showed that previously existing bowel bag definitions predominantly focused on the pelvic region and did not provide a complete and practical description of the full abdominopelvic contour relative to structures consistently visible in all radiation therapy images. The proposed contouring strategy had 4 components: a definition, a list of inclusion and exclusion structures, 15 tabulated operational definitions, and a set of atlases. The bowel bag was defined as the peritoneal cavity and retroperitoneal duodenum and ascending and descending colon, as visualized at the time of image acquisition. The operational definitions formalized the location of the peritoneal fascial planes through a simple look-up table. The proposed contouring strategy and reference atlases were successfully used on both TPCT and CBCT images. Conclusions This study produced a practical contouring strategy and reference atlases to enable reproducible delineation of the full bowel bag on TPCT and CBCT images. The strategy is a necessary first step toward consensus contouring with reduced observer variability, which is a prerequisite for evaluation of cumulative dose and its correlation with toxic effects, adaptive planning strategies, and automated contouring potential.
| S-EPMC9450071 | biostudies-literature
Project description:Different cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) protocols have shown promising results for imaging furcation defects. This study evaluates the suitability of low-dose (LD)-CBCT for this purpose. Fifty-nine furcation defects of nine upper and 16 lower molars in six human cadavers were measured by a high-dose (HD)-CBCT protocol, a LD-CBCT protocol, and a surgical protocol. HD-CBCT and LD-CBCT measurements were made twice by two investigators and were compared with the intrasurgical measurements, which served as the reference. Furcation defect volumes generated from HD-CBCT and LD-CBCT imaging were segmented by one rater. Cohen's kappa and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) values were calculated to determine intra- and interrater reliability. The level of significance was set at α = 0.05. In total, 59 furcation defects of nine upper and 16 lower human molars were assessed. Comparing CBCT furcation defect measurements with surgical measurements revealed a Cohen's kappa of 0.5975 (HD-and LD-CBCT), indicating moderate agreement. All furcation defects identified by HD-CBCT were also detected by LD-CBCT by both raters, resulting in a Cohen's kappa of 1. For interrater agreement, linear furcation defect measurements showed an ICC of 0.992 for HD-CBCT and 0.987 for LD-CBCT. The intrarater agreement was 0.994(r1)/0.992(r2) for HD-CBCT and 0.987(r1)/0.991(r2) for LD-CBCT. The intermodality agreement was 0.988(r1)/0.991(r2). Paired t-test showed no significant differences between HD-CBCT and LD-CBCT measurements. LD-CBCT is a precise and reliable method for detecting and measuring furcation defects in mandibular and maxillary molars in this experimental setting. It has the potential to improve treatment planning and treatment monitoring with a far lower radiation dose than conventional HD-CBCT.
| S-EPMC9043180 | biostudies-literature
Project description:AimThe objective of this research was to measure the labial bone thickness (LBT) in relation to the 6 anterior maxillary teeth at different levels along the long axis and the distance between cementoenamel junction and bone crest (CEJ-BC) based on cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) scans retrieved from patients of Arab ethnicity and identify any association with patients' characteristics.Materials and methodsA total of 100 CBCT scans were evaluated by one calibrated examiner. The thickness of the labial bone was measured perpendicular to the long axis of the tooth at 1, 3, and 5 mm from the alveolar crest (LBT-1, LBT-3, and LBT-5, respectively) and CEJ-BC using a medical imaging viewer.ResultsCBCT scans of 58 female patients and 42 male patients with a mean age of 39.7 ± 9.5 years were included. A high variation of CEJ-BC was observed (range, 0.55-3.90 mm). Statistically significant higher CEJ-BC values were associated with men and increased age (>50 years). The overall means of LBT-1 were 0.76 ± 0.26, 0.79 ± 0.26, and 0.83 ± 0.37 mm; LBT-3: 0.92 ± 0.36, 1.05 ± 0.46, and 1.03 ± 0.48 mm; LBT-5: 1.17 ± 0.52, 0.80 ± 0.45, and 0.81 ± 0.40 mm for central incisors, lateral incisors, and canines, respectively. The LBT was <1 mm in 74.2% of all maxillary anterior teeth, with central incisors showing the highest predilection (85% with LBT <1 mm). No significant association between LBT and patient characteristics was observed.ConclusionsThe CEJ-BC distance is greater in men and increases with age, particularly in those aged 50 years and older. The LBT in the 6 maxillary anterior teeth is predominantly thin (<1 mm) and has no correlation to age or sex. An increased LBT was observed at a 3-mm level when compared with LBT-1 and LBT-5. Such variability should be taken into consideration when planning for implant placement.
| S-EPMC10023538 | biostudies-literature
Project description:PurposeAnastomosis between posterior superior alveolar artery and infraorbital artery can go through bony canal in the lateral wall of the maxilla. This artery is called alveolar antral artery. It can complicate lateral sinus lift procedure by bleeding and hemosinus formation or bone graft wash out. The artery can also go in soft tissues where is not visible on cone beam computed tomography. In previous studies, the relation of this artery to sinus floor or alveolar process was measured. These structures are highly unstable during lifetime and after tooth loss. The aim of this study is to study presence and relations of bony canal in the lateral maxillary wall, to characterize the group of patients which is more likely to have bone canal in the lateral maxilla. The aim and the novelty of this study is the describing of the relationship of the bony canal to the more stable structure of hard palate and describing the relation of presence of bony canal on width of maxillary sinus, and to facilitate the prediction of presence of the alveolar antral artery.MaterialsThe cone beam computed tomography scans of the patients (251 in number) of the university hospital were examined for presence of alveolar antral artery (148 was fulfilled inclusion criteria), patient were characterized by gender, age, and sinus type (wide, average, narrow). The diameter of the bony canal and its relation to the level of sinus floor and hard palate were measured.ResultsThe cone beam computed tomography scans of 148 patients, out of it 55 man (37,2%) and 93 women (62,8%). Bony canal containing alveolar anastomosis was found in 69 cases (57,0%). Presence of the bony canal in the lateral wall of maxillae showed statistical probability depending on age with p = 0, 064 according to Mann-Whitney test. The older patients have more likely the bony canal. The presence of the alveolar antral artery was found more likely in the wide sinuses. The hard palate level can serve as a prediction point of alveolar antral artery only in first molar and second premolar region. In accordance with previous studies the width of bony canal is significantly higher in group of man (p = 0, 015). There was found a correlation between smaller distance of bony canal from sinus floor in the presence of teeth (p = 0, 067). After tooth loss the distance between sinus floor and bony canal increases, but the distance of bony canal to hard palate level stays constant. This can be explained hypothetically so that periodontal ligaments and root surface acts as a barrier for sinus pneumatization.ConclusionLateral sinus lifting in some cases can be unenviable, the knowledge about alveolar antral artery anatomy can reduce the risk of arterial bleeding. The cone-beam computed tomography is a routine examination prior to augmentation surgery and therefore the data obtained from it has an impact on clinical practice.
| S-EPMC10693819 | biostudies-literature
Project description:ObjectiveTo estimate the projected cancer risk attributable to diagnostic cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) performed under different exposure settings for orthodontic purposes in children and adults.MethodsWe collected a list of CBCT machines and their specifications from 38 orthodontists. Organ doses were estimated using median and maximum exposure settings of 105 kVp/156.8 mAs and 130 kVp/200 mAs, respectively. The projected cancer risk attributable to CBCT procedures performed 1-3 times within 2 years was calculated for children (aged 5 and 10 years) and adult (aged 20, 30, and 40 years) male and female patients.ResultsFor maximum exposure settings, the mean lifetime fractional ratio (LFR) was 14.28% for children and 0.91% for adults; this indicated that the risk to children was 16 times the risk to adults. For median exposure settings, the mean LFR was 5.25% and 0.58% for children and adults, respectively. The risk of cancer decreased with increasing age. For both median and maximum exposure settings, females showed a higher risk of cancer than did males in all age groups. Cancer risk increased with an increase in the frequency of CBCT procedures within a given period.ConclusionsThe projected dental CBCT-associated cancer risk spans over a wide range depending on the machine parameters and image acquisition settings. Children and female patients are at a higher risk of developing cancer associated with diagnostic CBCT. Therefore, the use of diagnostic CBCT should be justified, and protective measures should be taken to minimize the harmful biological effects of radiation.
| S-EPMC8133899 | biostudies-literature