Dataset Information

Limitations of using micro-computed tomography to predict bone-implant contact and mechanical fixation.

ABSTRACT: Fixation of metallic implants to bone through osseointegration is important in orthopaedics and dentistry. Model systems for studying this phenomenon would benefit from a non-destructive imaging modality so that mechanical and morphological endpoints can more readily be examined in the same specimens. The purpose of this study was to assess the utility of an automated microcomputed tomography (?CT) program for predicting bone-implant contact (BIC) and mechanical fixation strength in a rat model. Femurs in which 1.5-mm-diameter titanium implants had been in place for 4 weeks were either embedded in polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) for preparation of 1-mm-thick cross-sectional slabs (16 femurs: 32 slabs) or were used for mechanical implant pull-out testing (n= 18 femurs). All samples were scanned by ?CT at 70 kVp with 16 ?m voxels and assessed by the manufacturer's software for assessing 'osseointegration volume per total volume' (OV/TV). OV/TV measures bone volume per total volume (BV/TV) in a 3-voxel-thick ring that by default excludes the 3 voxels immediately adjacent to the implant to avoid metal-induced artefacts. The plastic-embedded samples were also analysed by backscatter scanning electron microscopy (bSEM) to provide a direct comparison of OV/TV with a well-accepted technique for BIC. In ?CT images in which the implant was directly embedded within PMMA, there was a zone of elevated attenuation (>50% of the attenuation value used to segment bone from marrow) which extended 48 ?m away from the implant surface. Comparison of the bSEM and ?CT images showed high correlations for BV/TV measurements in areas not affected by metal-induced artefacts. In addition for bSEM images, we found that there were high correlations between peri-implant BV/TV within 12 ?m of the implant surface and BIC (correlation coefficients ?0.8, p < 0.05). OV/TV as measured on ?CT images was not significantly correlated with BIC as measured on the corresponding bSEM images. However, OV/TV was significantly, but weakly, correlated with implant pull-out strength (r= 0.401, p= 0.049) and energy to failure (r= 0.435, p= 0.035). Thus, the need for the 48-?m-thick exclusion zone in the OV/TV program to avoid metal-induced artefacts with the scanner used in this study means that it is not possible to make bone measurements sufficiently close to the implant surface to obtain an accurate assessment of BIC. Current generation laboratory-based ?CT scanners typically have voxel sizes of 6-8 ?m or larger which will still not overcome this limitation. Thus, peri-implant bone measurements at these resolutions should only be used as a guide to predict implant fixation and should not be over-interpreted as a measurement of BIC. Newer generation laboratory-based ?CT scanners have several improvements including better spatial resolution and X-ray sources and appear to have less severe metal-induced artefacts, but will need appropriate validation as they become available to researchers. Regardless of the ?CT scanner being used, we recommend that detailed validation studies be performed for any study using metal implants because variation in the composition and geometry of the particular implants used may lead to different artefact patterns.

SUBMITTER: Liu S

PROVIDER: S-EPMC3767165 | biostudies-literature | 2012 Jan

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Limitations of using micro-computed tomography to predict bone-implant contact and mechanical fixation.

Liu S S Broucek J J Virdi A S AS Sumner D R DR

Journal of microscopy 20110915 1

Fixation of metallic implants to bone through osseointegration is important in orthopaedics and dentistry. Model systems for studying this phenomenon would benefit from a non-destructive imaging modality so that mechanical and morphological endpoints can more readily be examined in the same specimens. The purpose of this study was to assess the utility of an automated microcomputed tomography (μCT) program for predicting bone-implant contact (BIC) and mechanical fixation strength in a rat model. ...[more]

PMID: 21919905

Similar Datasets

Project description:This study used available or purchased equipment and an image reconstruction system developed by the college of dentistry to establish a basic self-assembled micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) system. Such a system would be suitable for teaching dental radiology to dental students. Specifically, it could help students to understand the principles governing dental cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) and provide graduate students with a system for scanning small samples (e.g., individual teeth) during the early stages of research. The self-assembled micro-CT system was constructed using a portable dental X-ray tube, an intraoral digital X-ray detector, a high-precision rotation stage, related bracket accessories, and a notebook computer. Reconstructed images and three-dimensional models of the maxillary right third molar were produced using the self-assembled micro-CT system and an advanced commercially available micro-CT system (Skyscan 2211). Subsequently, the reconstructed images and 3D models produced using the two systems were compared by two senior dentists to determine whether considerable visual differences could be observed. Finally, the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) was used for quantitative analysis and to compare the systems. Although the self-assembled micro-CT system produced image boundaries that were not as sharp as those of Skyscan 2211, the images were nonetheless remarkably similar. In addition, the two micro-CT systems produced 3D models that were almost identical in appearance and root canal shape. Quantitative analysis revealed that Skyscan 2211 had produced a SNR that was superior to that of the self-assembled micro-CT system, with the difference ranging from 36.77% to 136.22%; enamel, which has a higher density, exhibited lower SNR differences, whereas dentin, which has a lower density, exhibited higher SNR differences. The self-assembled micro-CT system with a resolution of 36 μm was created using a portable dental X-ray tube and an intraoral digital X-ray detector. Although the scanning time was relatively long (~30 min to scan images of a tooth), the images were adequate in the preliminary stage of experiments. More importantly, students were afforded the opportunity to observe the process of assembling and disassembling each component of a micro-CT scanner and thereby achieve a more comprehensive understanding of the principles governing micro-CT and dental CBCT.

Dataset Information

Limitations of using micro-computed tomography to predict bone-implant contact and mechanical fixation.

Publications

Limitations of using micro-computed tomography to predict bone-implant contact and mechanical fixation.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets