Dataset Information

Comparison of four clinically validated testosterone LC-MS/MS assays: Harmonization is an attainable goal.

ABSTRACT:

Introduction

Immunoassays and liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry assays are commonly employed in clinical laboratories for measurement of total testosterone in serum. Results obtained from either of these methodologies compare poorly due to differences in calibration and/or inadvertent detection of interfering substances by the immunoassays. Standardization efforts are underway, but recent studies indicate that accuracy remains an issue.

Methods

This study compares the results from four independently developed and validated LC-MS/MS assays for total testosterone. The calibration for each assay was verified using National Institute of Standards and Technology Standard Reference Material 971.

Results

Initially, one of the four assays had a mean percent difference of +11.44%, compared to the All Method Mean, but following re-verification of all five non-zero calibrator concentrations with the NIST SRM 971, the mean percent difference decreased to -4.88%. Subsequently, the agreement between all four assays showed a mean bias of <5% across the range of all testosterone concentrations (0.13-38.10 nmol/L; 3.7-1098 ng/dL), including at low concentrations of <1 nmol/L (<29 ng/dL).

Conclusions

Excellent agreement between four independently developed LC-MS/MS assays demonstrates that harmonization using standard reference material is attainable. However, as we found in this study, to ensure accurate calibration it is critical to validate the concentrations of new lots of calibrators.

SUBMITTER: French D

PROVIDER: S-EPMC8620848 | biostudies-literature |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Similar Datasets

Project description:BackgroundHighly accurate and sensitive method to measure testosterone in hypogonadal male, female and children is vital for proper diagnosis of hormone-related conditions and their treatment.ObjectiveTo develop an accurate and robust total testosterone ESI-LC-MS/MS quantification method with a simple sample preparation workflow and sufficient sensitivity for serum or plasma samples of all gender and age groups, via ketone functional group derivatization (using Amplifex™ Keto Reagent).MethodA simple sample preparation method to accommodate both low and high numbers of samples was developed using simultaneous protein precipitation and derivatization with Amplifex™ Keto reagent, followed by centrifugation and direct injection of supernatant into an LC-MS/MS system (SCIEX Topaz™ IVD LC-MS/MS, in which MS is equivalent to a SCIEX 4500MD Mass Spectrometer). Total testosterone in human serum or plasma samples was quantified using an external calibration curve generated by calibrators spanning a broad concentration range of ∼1-2000 ng/dL (10-20,000 pg/mL), traceable to NIST 971 SRM. 13C3-enriched testosterone was used as an internal standard to correct for both analyte loss during sample preparation and matrix effect during analysis (Supplementary Information: SI Fig. 4C). Two methods, one using a 96-well filter plate and another using Eppendorf tubes, were developed. Both methods were certified by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) hormone standardization (HoSt) program for total serum testosterone. The feasibility of implementing the method for plasma and serum samples was tested via a small-scale method comparison study between matched pediatric serum and plasma samples derived from the same donor. In addition, plasma samples originating from the same donor collected in two different anticoagulant tube types (Li-heparin and K2EDTA) were compared.ResultsUsing in-house formulated NIST 971-traceable calibrators, the method was linear (r2 > 0.999) between 1 and 2000 ng/dL (10 and 20,000 pg/mL) with a limit of detection of approximately 1 ng/dL (10 pg/mL). The testosterone concentration bias against 40 reference samples from the HoSt certification program was absolute <3% with an average %CV of ∼3-4%. More than 78% of samples passed the CDC bias criterion of ±6.4%. Comparison between pediatric matched serum and plasma samples resulted in high correlation (r2 = 0.997) and bias of <5%. The calculated % difference between matched adult serum and plasma samples was ∼1%.ConclusionsFeasibility for an accurate and streamlined method suitable for measuring total testosterone in all human samples was demonstrated with a choice of sample preparation workflow to suit low or high number of samples. The method can potentially be used for plasma matrix from different blood collection tubes (Li-Heparin and K2EDTA).